Welcome | View My Profile | Sign Out
MediaPost Home About MediaPost Privacy/Terms Media Kit Sitemap
Publications Home News
Online Media Daily Media Daily News Marketing Daily Mobile Marketing Daily Search Marketing Daily
Daily Feed> Email Daily Feed> Video Daily Feed> Social
Online Blogs
Online Spin Email Insider Search Insider Behavioral Insider Online Publishing Insider Mobile Insider Video Insider Gaming Insider Performance Insider Metrics Insider Social Media Insider Just An Online Minute Daily Online Examiner Raw Blog
Media Blogs
Research Brief Diane Mermigas:On Media TV Watch TV Board Magazine Rack Media Creativity Notes From the Digital Frontier Digital Outsider Mad Blog Red White and Blog
Marketing Blogs
Engage:Hispanics Engage:Kids 6-11 Engage:Moms Engage:Boomers Engage:Gen Y Engage:Teens Marketing:Green Marketing:Sports
Magazines
OMMA Magazine Media Magazine
Subscribe
Feedback Loop RSS Feeds Archives Subscribe
Dec 2 Search Insider Summit (Utah) Dec 6 Email Insider Summit (Utah) Jan 11 OMMA Agency of the Year (NYC) Jan 12 MEDIA Agency of the Year (NYC) Jan 26 OMMA Social (San Francisco) Jan 27 OMMA Performance (SF) Feb 24 OMMA Metrics Measurement (NYC) Feb 25 OMMA Behavioral (NYC) Mar 15 OMMA Global (San Francisco) Apr 14 Search Insider Summit (FL) Apr 18 Email Insider Summit (FL)
Recently Concluded Events
Nov 3 OMMA Adnets (NYC) Oct 30 OMMA Video (LA) Oct 29 OMMA Mobile (LA) Oct 29 OMMA Mobile & Video (LA) Sep 23 Creative Media Awards (NYC) Sep 23 The Future Of Media (NYC) Sep 22 Online All Stars (NYC) Sep 21 OMMA Awards (NYC) Sep 21 MediaPost Live at Advertising Week All-Access (NYC) Sep 21 OMMA Global New York (NYC)
All MediaPost/OMMA Events Event Blogging Past Event Videos
Industry Events Calendar
2010 OMMA Agency of the Year 2010 MEDIA Agency of the Year
2009 Creative Media Awards 2009 OMMA Awards 2009 Digital Out-of-Home Awards 2009 Media Agency of the Year 2009 OMMA Agency of the Year
All Awards
Employment Situations Wanted Services Offered Post a Job
Briefs Reports Online
MediaPost Directories
Mobile Insiders Group
People Finder Edit My Profile View My Profile My Contacts My Calendar
HOME • MANAGE SUBSCRIPTIONS • MEDIA KIT
YouTube's Search Fix
by Mark Simon, Monday, February 19, 2007, 11:15 AM

SHARE

TOOLS

RELATED ARTICLES

MOST READ

In the midst of ongoing frictions between YouTube and Big Media, I'd like to suggest a change that could help both sides. To fight piracy and provide more value to the entertainment industry, YouTube should alter its site search ranking to favor its partners -- the roughly 25 big media players like Sony Pictures, Capitol Records, and NBC, each of whom have their own channels within YouTube.

I say this because, increasingly, YouTube's site search is the video-search tool of choice for the video downloading set. And as is the case with any search tool, higher-ranking YouTube results are more likely to get viewed, while lower-ranking ones get ignored. By placing Partners on top of YouTube search rankings, YouTube would effectively hand viewership over to its partners, while forcing pirates -- who compete for that same viewership -- down into obscurity.

This kind of favoring wouldn't just fight pirates, either. It could also improve relevancy. A YouTube search for "The Office" is probably a search for video footage from the NBC show -- rather than, say, for the user-generated parody that currently outranks NBC's own YouTube clip. Giving partners the top slot would have made the NBC footage come before the parody, making searchers happier. Multiply that increased relevancy over every partner title a YouTube searcher could look for, and you'll see the value I'm talking about.

Despite all the reasons for favoring partner videos, though, YouTube doesn't seem to feature such an approach in its game plan.

Let's go back to the "Office" clip. NBC's clip is actually outranked by three clips, not one -- driving NBC below-the-fold on a typical laptop. The first and second competing results are taken from the show and a deleted scene, respectively, and both are posted by YouTube users.

Meanwhile, a search for ABC's "Lost" -- which has its own YouTube channel -- yielded none of the "Lost" channel's clips on the first two results pages. Many of the clips that did appear were "Lost" parodies.

Adult Swim, whose "Aqua Teen Hunger Force" you may recognize from the scare it caused in Boston, is yet another YouTube partner. Its channel features a promo clip for the upcoming Aqua Teen movie, but a YouTube search on that show's name features no Adult Swim postings on the first two results pages. Those pages do feature what appear to be pirated full-length episodes.

To be sure, the partner channels aren't being ignored. As I write this, NBC has the fourth-most-viewed channel on all of YouTube at 831,007 views, and partner channels' clips do appear on the homepage's "Featured Videos" and "Director Video" slots.

But the partners are undoubtedly losing viewership because it's hard to find them. And it's not just a problem of search listings: to get to a partner channel's main page, you need to find a button that's hidden two pages away from the home page -- which is hardly prime visibility.

Why haven't partners made an issue of their poor standing in YouTube search? Maybe because Big Media hasn't yet fully grasped search's value. Consider ABC -- which offers full-length downloads of its most popular shows, surely placing it amongst the most Web-forward of the big media giants. When it comes to search, ABC.com is clearly lagging.

For starters, the page on which ABC.com visitors can download full-length ABC programs has minimal HTML text -- even though HTML is the language that search engines read best. Even the names of the shows themselves are absent from the page's HTML. Title tags are also critical for organic rankings, but the page's title tag -- "ABC.com full episode player" -- doesn't mention the word "download." I could go on, but suffice it to say that it's not surprising that on the term "download lost," ABC.com is absent from Google's first organic result page.

Actually, ABC.com doesn't appear on the Google paid listings for "download lost" either: this, even though at least 10 downloading services are advertising in Google on that term. And ABC, again, is a true leader of the online pack amongst the big media -- you can only imagine where the followers stand with search.

And so in the midst of the give-and-take over online piracy, both YouTube and the big media companies are missing opportunities all around. YouTube needs to assuage its frictions with Big Media, as it's their content that draws much of its traffic. Big Media knows that TV won't last forever, so it needs to find a new channel for distributing video. As the leader among social video sites, YouTube is the perfect candidate to become that new channel.

Obviously, the concerns on each sides are real. For a way out of their current deadlock, each side should be looking to the search bar.

4 comments on "YouTube's Search Fix"

  1. steve plunkett from M/C/C
    commented on: February 20, 2007 at 9:53 AM
    The answer would be SEO within YouTube... but since that seems to be rocket science for you guys (did-it.com folks), it would explain your view point. Which is a good reminder to check some stuff this week on YouTube. Good article, time to do SEO for some clients videos... :)

    SEO.. 3 out of 4 rocket scientists don't get it either.

  2. E Trainor from Covenant Enterprises
    commented on: February 19, 2007 at 7:22 PM
    Great idea! Legitimize YouTube as a search engine and as a marketing platform.

  3. Mike McGrath from RealXstream PTY LTD
    commented on: February 19, 2007 at 1:40 PM
    If YouTube were to do this, or something similar, then this would also provide a good reason for independent channels that might currently shy away from YouTube because they offer no real advantages, to partner with them also. My company www.realxstream.com for example…

  4. Will Zaichkowski from Cranial Interactive
    commented on: February 19, 2007 at 12:59 PM
    The last time I checked, Youtube evolved as a medium for user generated content. You suggest that Youtube needs to skew rankings to favour partners - which kinda knoocks the stuffing out of the original intent (and if I may add,the whole reason Youtube was popular in the first place). I agree, however; that the producers need to figure out search - and if they want to do that they need to look at the priates and see what they are doing. Despite being illegal, they have managed to attain higher rankings than the producers and distributers. Like all criminals, they have an understanding of the interpersonal marketplace - the economy that exists in a one to one relationship that takes places in front of the open trunk of a car in a mall parking lot. The bottom line is the producers and distributers can either find a path to the consumer, or buy a path. In an establihment-shy marketplace I suspect only one of those approaches is going to work, and I am pretty sure it's not the choice they'll make.

Leave a Comment

You must be signed in to comment. Sign In

Do you have strong opinions and inside knowledge about the topic of this article -- and do you want to share your insights, observations and points of view regularly with the readers of MediaPost? To be considered as a MediaPost contributing writer, please send pertinent info about your credentials, plus several column ideas and one example of your writing on the topic, to pfine@mediapost.com. Please see our editorial guidelines here first.

MARK SIMON
  • Mark Simon is vice president of industry relations at Didit, an agency for search engine marketing and auctioned media management based in New York. You can reach Mark at msimon@didit.com.


AUTHORS

ARCHIVES

RECENT VIDEOS
Recent Search Insider Articles
What's Going To Work? TEAMWORK   
If you have a child in the 18- to 36-month-old range, you may recognize the catchphrase...
Search Insider Sneak Peek: The Three-For-One Keynote   
Avinash Kaushik, Google's Analytics Evangelist, will be kicking off the Search Insider Summit in just two...
Even More On: Everything I Need to Know About Business I Learned From Google   
Today we close out the chapter on business lessons learned from Google. As much as I...
Search Is For The Drills; Social Is For The Holes   
How do people engage with your product or service? Do you sell something like kayaks, which...
Applied Video & Social Search   
So I am sitting around with some friends last weekend watching sports on TV. We get...
Rebranding Myself   
This past Saturday, I married the love of my life. Now begins the process of changing...
SIS Sneak Peek: Looking Backward AND Forward   
In about three weeks, we'll be gathering in Park City, Utah for another Search Insider Summit....
PPC: Commercial Real-Time Search (Almost) Realized    
For all of the focus on crawler and social layers, paid search has largely been ignored...
Finding That One Blue Marble   
In the months straddling 2000-2001, I had the good fortune to lead the ParentsConnected Nationwide Seminar...
The Failure To (Completely) Serve    
At Ad:Tech last week, one message I heard, over and over again, is that people seem...
>> Search Insider Archives 
ABOUT MEDIAPOST • MASTHEAD • MEDIA KIT • RSS FEEDS • PRIVACY/TERMS & CONDITIONS
©2009 MediaPost Communications. All rights reserved.
1140 Broadway, 4th Floor, New York, NY 10001
tel. 212-204-2000, fax 212-204-2038, feedback@mediapost.com