Welcome | View My Profile | Sign Out
MediaPost Home About MediaPost Privacy/Terms Media Kit Sitemap
Publications Home News
Online Media Daily Media Daily News Marketing Daily Mobile Marketing Daily Search Marketing Daily
Daily Feed> Email Daily Feed> Video Daily Feed> Social
Online Blogs
Online Spin Email Insider Search Insider Behavioral Insider Online Publishing Insider Mobile Insider Video Insider Gaming Insider Performance Insider Metrics Insider Social Media Insider Just An Online Minute Daily Online Examiner Raw Blog
Media Blogs
Research Brief Diane Mermigas:On Media TV Watch TV Board Magazine Rack Media Creativity Notes From the Digital Frontier Digital Outsider Mad Blog Red White and Blog
Marketing Blogs
Engage:Hispanics Engage:Kids 6-11 Engage:Moms Engage:Boomers Engage:Gen Y Engage:Teens Marketing:Green Marketing:Sports
Magazines
OMMA Magazine Media Magazine
Subscribe
Feedback Loop RSS Feeds Archives Subscribe
Dec 2 Search Insider Summit (Utah) Dec 6 Email Insider Summit (Utah) Jan 11 OMMA Agency of the Year (NYC) Jan 12 MEDIA Agency of the Year (NYC) Jan 26 OMMA Social (San Francisco) Jan 27 OMMA Performance (SF) Feb 24 OMMA Metrics Measurement (NYC) Feb 25 OMMA Behavioral (NYC) Mar 15 OMMA Global (San Francisco) Apr 14 Search Insider Summit (FL) Apr 18 Email Insider Summit (FL)
Recently Concluded Events
Nov 3 OMMA Adnets (NYC) Oct 30 OMMA Video (LA) Oct 29 OMMA Mobile (LA) Oct 29 OMMA Mobile & Video (LA) Sep 23 Creative Media Awards (NYC) Sep 23 The Future Of Media (NYC) Sep 22 Online All Stars (NYC) Sep 21 OMMA Awards (NYC) Sep 21 MediaPost Live at Advertising Week All-Access (NYC) Sep 21 OMMA Global New York (NYC)
All MediaPost/OMMA Events Event Blogging Past Event Videos
Industry Events Calendar
2010 OMMA Agency of the Year 2010 MEDIA Agency of the Year
2009 Creative Media Awards 2009 OMMA Awards 2009 Digital Out-of-Home Awards 2009 Media Agency of the Year 2009 OMMA Agency of the Year
All Awards
Employment Situations Wanted Services Offered Post a Job
Briefs Reports Online
MediaPost Directories
Mobile Insiders Group
People Finder Edit My Profile View My Profile My Contacts My Calendar
HOME • MANAGE SUBSCRIPTIONS • MEDIA KIT
Lies, Damn Lies & Statistics
by Randy Kilgore, Monday, August 13, 2007, 10:30 AM

SHARE

TOOLS

RELATED ARTICLES

MOST READ

Is this what it feels like to be Paris Hilton? The non-stop buzz, the speculation about your every move, who you've been seen associating with, all eyes on you all the time? That may be a stretch, but there certainly is a lot of buzz about online video. We are without a doubt the "it girl" of online marketing.

With the flood of online video research being conducted at the moment, separating fact from fiction can be as challenging as keeping tabs on the Hollywood rumor mill. Do 30-second ads "really" outperform 15-second ads? Is creating original Web advertising "really" the only way to go? The arguments for and against nearly every data point published are healthy for a growing industry finding its way, but after attending a slew of events focused on our space, hearing opinions from agencies, marketers and the creative community, I am reminded of the phrase that Mark Twain made famous, "There are three kinds of numbers: lies, damn lies, and statistics."

Most of the opinions that I hear seem biased toward the business model of the company the person works for. That makes sense, of course, considering the limited amount of research available. And, as Mark Twain implied, there are plenty of ways to use accurate numbers to draw a less-than-conclusive conclusions. The broader question to consider, though, is what will we say in the face of data that contradicts our own opinions?

My high level view of the initial research is that things look pretty good for the online video advertising space. But it's important to understand the data and how it is being interpreted, while being careful not to get into a "paralysis by analysis" situation. Instead of talking about what is wrong, we should be digging into the numbers, considering their context, applying some common sense and experience, and driving our industry forward both for today and tomorrow. Despite the need for data and case studies to support our own initiatives, we can't afford not to heed Mr. Twain's warnings.

As many of you saw, I spoke on a panel at the OMMA Video conference last month. As you may recall, one of my co-panelists, a creative visionary for whom I have a tremendous amount of respect, followed me by saying, "I can't sit next to you any more. I'm in the complete opposite camp and think everything we're doing is absolutely horrible and we need to change everything." In case you need a reminder, or just a good chuckle, you can watch the video for yourself in MediaPost's video section.

As more data continues to pour into the market, we have to ask ourselves to do two things. First, take every study with a grain of salt. There are only so many factors any one particular study can focus on, and there's sure to be more questions than answers following each new report. Second, we need to accept the conclusions even when they don't necessarily fit with our own personal beliefs or corporate agendas.

While our creative cohorts may undervalue the power of pre-roll, or even loathe the format altogether, most of the recent data suggests that it's a powerful and effective ad format. The Online Publishers Association found that pre-roll video ads with static companion ads had the greatest impact on raising brand awareness. At a recent conference, Advertising.com's Aimee Irwin presented data that showed that pre-roll outperformed in-banner video across all metrics. In fact, the pre-roll ad generated six times as many clicks as the campaign's display ads.

Additionally, Irwin's data showed that higher frequency ( 3 or 4+ exposures) had a positive impact on message association and favorability. Counterintuitive? Maybe. But what will we say about frequency and the user experience the next time we get together?


Another common opinion that we hear is that creative produced for the Web will be better than repurposed content from other mediums. However, the OPA study, published in June, found that there was no major difference between the two. Yet at the same conference that Irwin presented her data, a co-panelist presented a slide that stated, "Content developed specifically for the application will always be more effective than repurposing broadcast assets." While I'd be very hesitant, especially in light of the short supply of research into this particular area, to draw any conclusions yet, the data says otherwise.

Lastly, the OPA study found that both :15 and :30 second spots were effective in lifting brand metrics. In fact, the :30 outpaced the :15 for ad likability. The IAB, as well as other individual companies, will be launching research into this area shortly, but a little common sense can go a long way in this particular area.

I'm sure we can all agree that a :30 second ad has no place in front of a short, user-generated clip on your favorite video sharing site. However, consider ABC's launch of its new high-definition video player. Is seeing two :30 second ads over the course of 50 minutes of programming, such as "Lost," an unfair value exchange? Absolutely not. It enables viewers to watch a program when they want, where they want, with fewer ads than watching on TV, while offering advertisers a very reasonable CPM.

I'm not suggesting that we don't explore new forms of video advertising. In fact, I believe some of the new formats available today are fantastic tools to add to our arsenal of ad opportunities. But while the data supports the use of pre-roll and leveraging our current video assets, advertisers should take advantage of the earlier adopter phase before the landscape is overly saturated.


With eMarketer estimating $4.3 billion being spent in online video advertising within the next four years, and more than half of online Americans watching at least some online video, there will be plenty of opportunity and funding for us to explore nearly every aspect of online video advertising. In the meantime, let's focus on what is good about online video advertising, and help our clients begin the transition so they'll be ready for that next big idea when it gets here -- rather than scaring them back into the stone age of static gifs.

1 person recommends this article. 

3 comments on "Lies, Damn Lies & Statistics "

  1. corey kronengold from Tremor Media
    commented on: August 14, 2007 at 9:49 AM
    Doug- True enough that Disraeli said it first. Twain made it popular, citing Disraeli . Carefully chosen words vetted by the shlocky PR guy.

    From Twain's "Chapters from My Autobiography":

    Figures often beguile me, particularly when I have the arranging of them myself; in which case the remark attributed to Disraeli would often apply with justice and force:

    "There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics."

    Carefully chosen words vetted by the shlocky PR guy. ;-)

  2. Doug McFarland from Scanscout
    commented on: August 13, 2007 at 5:54 PM
    Like the article, Randy. Only one thing: The quotation, ‘lies, damnable lies, and statistics’ is from Benjamin Disraeli, though often mis-cited to Mark Twain.

    Doug McFarland/ScanScout

  3. Michael Kildale from 180flowers.com
    commented on: August 13, 2007 at 2:07 PM
    Couldn't agree more on the points regarding contradictory information being provided on what works and what does not in the online video advertising space. It will basically come down to a brand by brand execution to see what works best for their company. The only pieces of information I see missing on many research packages are that of Direct Response Advertising vs Brand Adveritising for the video platform. Do we understand the difference in terms of best practices between these two areas? Would like to get your incite.

    Michael Kildale Director Interactive Marketing, 1800flowers.com

Leave a Comment

You must be signed in to comment. Sign In

Do you have strong opinions and inside knowledge about the topic of this article -- and do you want to share your insights, observations and points of view regularly with the readers of MediaPost? To be considered as a MediaPost contributing writer, please send pertinent info about your credentials, plus several column ideas and one example of your writing on the topic, to pfine@mediapost.com. Please see our editorial guidelines here first.

RANDY KILGORE
  • Randy Kilgore is chief revenue officer for Tremor Media, responsible for managing the company's sales and inventory growth. He was previously senior vice president of advertising for Dow Jones Online.


AUTHORS

ARCHIVES

RECENT VIDEOS
Recent Video Insider Articles
Rethinking Interactive TV Measurement   
While today's interactive experiences include on-screen polling and multiple choice questions, the scale required for nationwide...
Closing Out 2009: Trends In Video   
One of my favorite things about working for an ad network is the diversity of partners...
TV Listings Data Will Be King   
With video content delivery further decomposing into linear, time-shifting Internet, and video-on-demand buckets growing, it will...
What Hath Apple Wrought?   
In 1844 Samuel Morse's first message over a 40-mile experimental telegraph from Washington to Baltimore was...
Scientific Advertising And Free Samples   
Up until this year '' which many consider to be the turning point for interactivity --...
Open The Floodgates: Greater Access To Content Will Raise Studio Profits   
Making movies is like product development. Each new Adam Sandler comedy or zombie spookfest is essentially...
Information Superhighway Within Reach   
The Internet has evolved into an omnipresent force shaping, or destroying, all that swims in its...
Thriving In A Market That Rewards Quality And Volume   
I am often approached by publishers who want to grow video ad revenue and are willing...
Thanks To Technology, Video is Everywhere   
The 21st century is an era of mass technology, which has made mass information a commodity...
Avoiding Video Network Pitfalls   
The news over the past few weeks has been interesting, to say the least, when it...
>> Video Insider Archives 
ABOUT MEDIAPOST • MASTHEAD • MEDIA KIT • RSS FEEDS • PRIVACY/TERMS & CONDITIONS
©2009 MediaPost Communications. All rights reserved.
1140 Broadway, 4th Floor, New York, NY 10001
tel. 212-204-2000, fax 212-204-2038, feedback@mediapost.com