| ||||||||||||
PRINT
COMMENT
SUBSCRIBE
RSSAn effective email marketing program isn't just a big single-cell creature. It's an interconnected ecosystem, with many factors that affect its vitality. Using a limited set of metrics to measure performance can mislead you into thinking you're succeeding wildly or failing miserably.
Instead, use a "balanced scorecard" approach to get readings from all around the ecosystem and help you understand more clearly exactly how well you're really doing.
This concept, used often by companies to assess corporate performance beyond just financial measures (e.g., customer and employee satisfaction, innovation, brand strength, etc.), can help you grasp the bigger and more complicated picture.
Applied to email, this forces you to move beyond simple metrics such as revenue per campaign or opens and clicks. Both sets of statistics will give you only part of the picture, no matter how accurate they might be.
This concept goes along with my previous EmailInsider column in which I urged you to begin assessing the strength or weakness of your email program in terms of business goals, not just email-oriented metrics.
These seven factors are one example of what might make up the balanced scorecard for your email program:
1. List growth and health
2. Deliverability
3. Message level
4. Campaign performance over time
Meet Loren McDonald at Email Insider Summit Utah!
Loren McDonald will be there speaking during "Looking Past Email Measurement" on December 09 at 9:45 AM. Top executives will be there. Will you?
Register today and save.
Register today and save.
5. Conversion activity
6. Subscriber/customer engagement and relationship
7. Financial performance and ROI
Using the balanced scorecard can help you assess whether changes in your email program are ultimately helping or hurting it. One classic example is in deciding to increase message frequency in order to bring in more revenue -- a timely example as we head into the holiday shopping season.
If you rely only on bottom-line performance, you might think you've succeeded if you see an increase in number of orders, order size or total campaign revenue. This is actually what happened with one client that increased mailings from five a month to 12.
However, that increased frequency had a severe cost. Once we looked at process metrics, such as delivery rate, opens, unsubscribes and spam complaints, we uncovered a whole lot of subscriber unhappiness. Spam complaints and unsubscribes went through the roof, outpacing the revenue increase.
The total cost of boosting frequency -- reacquiring the subscribers who left, acquiring new ones, sending more campaigns, potential lost revenue -- would have actually cost the company money over the longer term and immediately harmed the client's sender reputation.
The balanced scorecard approach will help you spot problems in other areas so that you don't find yourself, six months down the road, wondering why you aren't making money anymore and why your email messages get blocked at every major ISP. And, it doesn't just help you avoid failing. It can also show you where you are succeeding when you want to measure things other than financial performance, such as customer engagement, list health, etc.
Yes, using a balanced scorecard will take more time and effort, but your reward is a more accurate picture of your email program's vitality and contribution to your corporate goals. That can help you justify your requests for a bigger share of the marketing-budget pie and for email's place as a strong channel in a multichannel marketing program.
RSS FEEDS
It tells you what your people don't want - which gives you information on what they do want
Preference center behavorial information helps you give consumers on your email list content they want and value
Peter Simmons - Director of Sales - UnsubCentral
Each email program is different so I would recommend studying your opt-outs to make such decisions. The common reason users unsubscribe & complain is when their perception of what they are opting in varies from what they actually receive. Using a Score Card such as outlined by Loren, some programs can try creating a life cycle and add a dollar value to a new registration. As you make changes to your program, you can study the cause and effect so you can better understand the factors influencing your email program and its affects on the life cycle. This way, if you increase the frequency you can study if there is an increase in the number of complaints, unsubscribe and delivery challenges. You can also study your Opt-outs by adding an option on your Opt-out page that lists the most common reason for Opting out including frequency, and ask users to provide feedback so you can learn why users don’t want to be on your list.
We also need to understand that increase in the registrations (signups) does not necessarily mean more revenue. Even the common perception that by growing your email list will get your message in front of a larger audience, in many cases, is not true either. The delivery challenges for the list that is collected as a result of a poor signup process effects the Reputation of the sender and results in getting its messages blocked or directed to the bulk folder by the ISP. If the signup process is clear and conspicuous then the growth of the list may drop but the value of the list will increase.
Let’s take a scenario where a sender already has a process similar to the one outline above. Now if the signup process is improved, then the sender can start tracking the new registrations separately, and can compare the dollar value of the user collected before and after the changes to understand if the changes are favorable to the business. Of course, all other factors need to be the same between the segments to run such tests and I always recommend running multiple tests to validate results when you are going to draw important decisions from it. On the other hand, if you don’t have a similar process in place then it becomes difficult to understand the cause and effect. However, if you don’t have enough resources to monitor your program so closely then you should continue to follow industry best practices.
I hope it helps! - Yanni
- Jen
Griff http://eprospector.typepad.com/small_business_sales_and_/