LexisNexis Publisher Backs Banks In 'Hot News' Reposting Case
Chiming in on a high-profile dispute, the business-to-business publishing company Reed Elsevier is asking a federal appeals court to uphold a finding that TheFlyOnTheWall.com misappropriates banks' "hot news" by reposting their stock recommendations.
Reed Elsevier says in a recent court filing that it could face "devastating economic effects" if it lost the ability to prevent other publishers from summarizing its time-sensitive material. The company runs news services like The Pink Sheet Daily, which offers updated news about the biopharmaceutical industry, and ICIS.com, a news service about the chemical industry. It also owns the LexisNexis databases.
"Reed Elsevier has invested and continues to invest billions of dollars in the collection, organization, and verification of the information provided through these services in print, email, and via the internet," the company says in its legal papers, adding that laws preventing misappropriation prevent "economically destructive conduct by those who wish to reap where they have not sown."
The current legal debate about hot news stems from a lawsuit by Barclays, Bank of America's Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley, alleging that the site TheFlyOnTheWall.com unlawfully posted summaries of the banks' time-sensitive research before their clients received the information.
U.S. District Court Judge Denise Cote in New York in March ruled in favor of the banks and ordered the TheFlyOnTheWall.com to refrain from publishing summaries of much of the banks' research until 10 a.m. on trading days -- even where other publishers had already posted the same material.
The Web site appealed and the Second Circuit lifted the injunction while it considers the matter.
Cote based her decision on a 1918 U.S. Supreme Court decision holding that rewriting another publication's scoops is actionable as a misappropriation of hot news.
That ruling has drawn much outside interest, with companies like Google and Twitter as well as digital rights groups backing TheFlyOnTheWall.com, while Reed Elsevier and others back the banks.
Google and Twitter argue that the concept that news can be time-sensitive no longer makes sense. "In a world of modern communications technology, where anyone with a cell phone may disseminate news throughout the world even as it is occurring, the notion that a single media outlet should have a monopoly on time-sensitive facts is not only contrary to law, it is, as a practical matter, futile," they argued.
Reed Elsevier specifically urges the court to reject Google and Twitter's argument, writing that the companies' position "represents a complete dismissal of the business reality that ... fact-laden information sources do not appear out of thin air, but instead require the maintenance of incentives so that their producers may continue to make them available to the public."
Recent Online Media Daily Articles
-
Affiliate Channels Attract Global Buying, Tailored Marketing Programs June 18, 5:54 p.m.
The Internet continues to make the world smaller for affiliate marketers, but there are physical challenges ... -
Microsoft Rolls Out Ad Pano, Mobile Ad Format June 18, 3:03 p.m.
With the help of the broader ad industry, Microsoft this week is rolling out a mobile ... -
Kiip Debuts Self-Serve Option For Advertisers June 18, 2:23 p.m.
Mobile rewards network Kiip has added a self-serve option for advertisers aimed at attracting more small- and ... -
Mindshare Taps Elkins As Managing Director, Digital, West Coast June 18, 1:51 p.m.
Mindshare, part of WPP's GroupM, has tapped digital marketing veteran Amy Elkins to be managing director, ... -
Blogging Stake: WPP Invests In Muzy June 18, 9:12 a.m.
WPP has taken a stake in Muzy Inc., an early-stage micro-blogging service focused on mobile content ... -
MSN, Newsy Partnership To Debut June 18, 7:40 a.m.
MSN on Tuesday is expected to announce a partnership with mobile-focused video news network Newsy. Similar to ... -
ZO Shaves Global Ad Outlook: Says Internet, Especially Mobile, Will Be Greatest Growth Engines June 18, 7:34 a.m.
The global ad economy now is expected to expand only 3.5% this year, according to the ... -
Google Enhanced Campaigns Increase Cost Per Click June 18, 12:05 a.m.
Search advertisers will need to learn how to compensate for rising costs per click as Google ... -
Publicis Groupe's VivaKi Influences Mass Relevance Social Road Map June 17, 9 p.m.
VivaKi Ventures has gained input into Mass Relevance's product road map to influence features and functions ... -
Facebook: Sponsored Stories Settlement Gives Users 'Windfall' June 17, 6:04 p.m.
Facebook is asking a federal judge to grant final approval to a $20 million deal that ...
Be the first to comment on "LexisNexis Publisher Backs Banks In 'Hot News' Reposting Case"
Leave a Comment