ComScore Loses Bid To Transfer Privacy Case To Virginia
Consumers who are suing comScore for allegedly duping them into installing monitoring software will be allowed to proceed with the lawsuit in Illinois, rather than transfer it to Virginia, a federal judge has ruled.
U.S. District Court Judge James Holderman rejected comScore's argument that the license agreement accompanying the software required transferring the case to Virginia. Holderman said in a written opinion that consumers alleged that the link to the terms of service was “obscured during the installation process” so that average consumers wouldn't notice the link.
"It is not reasonable to expect a user casually downloading free software to search for such an agreement if it is not immediately available and obvious where to obtain it,” Holderman wrote.
The litigation dates to August, when Illinois resident Mike Harris and California resident Jeff Dunstan sued comScore for allegedly bundling its monitoring software with programs that offer products like free screensavers.
The Web users say they weren't adequately notified that downloading the free programs would also result in the installation of comScore's tracking software -- which goes by various names, including RelevantKnowledge and PermissionResearch.
Harris and Dunstan allege that many users aren't told about the monitoring software until after they have begun installing it. Once users download the software, comScore can access their Web activity and use that information in its market research reports. The lawsuit accuses comScore of violating the federal wiretap law and computer fraud law as well as Illinois state laws. Harris and Dunstan are seeking class-action status.
Holderman's decision not to enforce the license agreement and transfer the case to Virginia, where comScore is headquartered, is raising some eyebrows among lawyers. Legal expert Venkat Balasubramani calls the ruling a "double-take-worthy decision," noting that other judges have said that "check the box terms" are enforceable. "If there were no issues with the UI [user interface] implementation or the browser, then the court's decision is off base," he writes.
Recent Online Media Daily Articles
-
Consumer Action: Most Web Users Want Control Over Tracking June 18, 8:20 p.m.
Most Web users have expectations about privacy that appear to be at odds with current practices ... -
Affiliate Channels Attract Global Buying, Tailored Marketing Programs June 18, 5:54 p.m.
The Internet continues to make the world smaller for affiliate marketers, but there are physical challenges ... -
Microsoft Rolls Out Ad Pano, Mobile Ad Format June 18, 3:03 p.m.
With the help of the broader ad industry, Microsoft this week is rolling out a mobile ... -
Kiip Debuts Self-Serve Option For Advertisers June 18, 2:23 p.m.
Mobile rewards network Kiip has added a self-serve option for advertisers aimed at attracting more small- and medium-sized ... -
Mindshare Taps Elkins As Managing Director, Digital, West Coast June 18, 1:51 p.m.
Mindshare, part of WPP's GroupM, has tapped digital marketing veteran Amy Elkins to be managing director, ... -
Blogging Stake: WPP Invests In Muzy June 18, 9:12 a.m.
WPP has taken a stake in Muzy Inc., an early-stage micro-blogging service focused on mobile content ... -
MSN, Newsy Partnership To Debut June 18, 7:40 a.m.
MSN on Tuesday is expected to announce a partnership with mobile-focused video news network Newsy. Similar to ... -
ZO Shaves Global Ad Outlook: Says Internet, Especially Mobile, Will Be Greatest Growth Engines June 18, 7:34 a.m.
The global ad economy now is expected to expand only 3.5% this year, according to the ... -
Google Enhanced Campaigns Increase Cost Per Click June 18, 12:05 a.m.
Search advertisers will need to learn how to compensate for rising costs per click as Google ... -
Publicis Groupe's VivaKi Influences Mass Relevance Social Road Map June 17, 9 p.m.
VivaKi Ventures has gained input into Mass Relevance's product road map to influence features and functions ...
Be the first to comment on "ComScore Loses Bid To Transfer Privacy Case To Virginia "
Leave a Comment