Appellate Court Nixes AOL Settlement Over Ads In Emails
A federal appellate court has rejected a deal calling for AOL to donate $110,000 to six groups, including the Boys and Girls Club of America, in order to settle class-action litigation about ads in emails.
In an opinion issued on Monday, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the organizations designated as recipients were inappropriate because they don't deal with Internet issues. The court sent the case back to the trial court for further proceedings.
“The parties should not have trouble selecting beneficiaries from any number of non-profit organizations that work to protect internet users from fraud, predation, and other forms of online malfeasance,” the 9th Circuit wrote. “If a suitable ... beneficiary cannot be located, the district court should consider escheating the funds to the United States Treasury,” the 9th Circuit ruled.
The settlement would have resolved two class-action lawsuits by members who complained that the ads were "annoying, confusing, intrusive and misleading” and that they violated a federal privacy law.
AOL began inserting ads in the email footers in 2006. Two years later, the company decided to allow paying subscribers to opt out of the ads; the following year, AOL changed its policy to allow everyone to opt out of the ads.
The agreement called on AOL to donate $110,000 to six charities: The Legal Aid Foundation for Los Angeles, the Federal Judicial Center Foundation, the Boys and Girls Club of America, New Roads School of Santa Monica, Oklahoma Indian Legal Services, and the Friars Foundation. (The latter three were chosen by the individual consumers who brought suit on behalf of the class.)
A trial judge approved the settlement over the objection of two AOL users. They appealed that decision and the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals sided with them, ruling that the charities named as recipients don't “have anything to do with the objectives of the underlying statutes on which Plaintiffs base their claims.”
Recent Online Media Daily Articles
-
Weather.com Develops Real-Time Data Ad Targeting May 17, 5:12 p.m.
Weather.com has begun using audience segmentation data from Lotame to develop real-time ad targeting services based ... -
MetroPCS Drops Challenge To Neutrality Rules May 17, 4:44 p.m.
T-Mobile's newly acquired MetroPCS withdrew its challenge to the Federal Communications Commission's net neutrality rules on ... -
'Geo-Conquesting' Drives Higher Mobile Click Rates May 17, 3:56 p.m.
The practice of conquesting -- running advertising for a brand or product near editorial content about ... -
Cox-Backed, Skyword Raises $6.7 Million To Enhance Content Creation May 17, 3:34 p.m.
Internet services and utilities will rely more on content as the industry matures. Shereta Williams, vice ... -
Ford, Jeep, Chevy Top Digital Auto Brands May 17, 1:09 p.m.
On the digital proving track, Detroit is beating out the competition. Ford, Jeep and Chevrolet were ... -
Choosing Sides: VivaKi Backs comScore; ABC Throws In With Nielsen May 17, 9:52 a.m.
In a battle to control the future of the ad industry’s currency, Nielsen and comScore each ... -
Yahoo Adds Tweets To News Feed May 16, 6:18 p.m.
Yahoo will incorporate selected tweets into the news feed on its redesigned home page through a ... -
Mozilla Puts Cookie-Blocking On Hold May 16, 6:16 p.m.
Mozilla is putting the brakes on plans to block third-party cookies by default in the upcoming ... -
Mobile Ad Results In Line With Rich Media May 16, 5:39 p.m.
Mobile display ads perform roughly on par with rich media ads in terms of click-through and ... -
Google Plans To Transition Brands Into Content-Driven Advertising May 16, 4:30 p.m.
Google wants technology to "step out of the way" as developers integrate it into everyday life. ...
Be the first to comment on "Appellate Court Nixes AOL Settlement Over Ads In Emails"
Leave a Comment