Appeals Court Allows Facebook's Beacon Settlement To Go Forward

Handing a victory to Facebook, a divided federal appellate court has decided against hearing additional arguments challenging the company's $9.5 million Beacon settlement.

The decision, issued Tuesday, leaves in place a prior ruling approving the deal, which calls for Facebook to fund a new privacy group. The agreement also requires the social networking giant to pay the 19 consumers who filed suit amounts varying from $1,000 to $15,000, while the company will pay around $3 million toward court costs and fees for the plaintiffs' lawyers who brought the case.

Facebook user and privacy advocate Ginger McCall challenged that settlement, arguing that Facebook would have too much control over the new organization, dubbed the Digital Trust Foundation. The foundation will be directed by a three-person board -- and Facebook will play a key role in selecting those people. (One of the board members was supposed to be Facebook's former public policy director, Tim Sparapani, but he left the company before the foundation was created.)

McCall also argued the deal didn't compensate users who were harmed by the defunct Beacon ad program, which shared information about people's ecommerce activity with their friends.

Last year, a panel of the 9th Circuit voted 2-1 to uphold the settlement, originally approved by U.S. District Court Judge Richard Seeborg. The two judges in the majority wrote that the settlement was "fundamentally fair," while Senior Circuit Judge Andrew Kleinfeld dissented. He wrote that the deal "perverts the class action into a device for depriving victims of remedies for wrongs, while enriching both the wrongdoers and the lawyers purporting to represent the class."

McCall then asked the entire 9th Circuit to consider the case. On Tuesday, a divided court declined to do so. Six appellate judges dissented from that decision. They said in a written opinion that the settlement "failed to be reasonably certain to benefit the class," or to "advance the objectives" of the wiretap law -- the statute the consumers cited in their lawsuit.

A Facebook spokesperson said the company was "pleased with the court's decision upholding the settlement" and looks forward to establishing the Digital Trust Foundation.

 



Recommend (1) Print RSS
  • FTC Calls For New Privacy Laws In Report On 'Internet Of Things'

    The potential privacy risks posed by the “Internet of Things,” or devices that connect with each other over the Web, is spurring the Federal Trade Commission to reiterate its calls for new legislation. “Although the Commission currently has authority to take action against some IoT-related practices, it cannot mandate certain ...
  • White House To Unveil Privacy 'Bill Of Rights'

    The White House will unveil a proposed privacy “bill of rights” by the end of next month, President Obama said on Monday. The measure will set out “basic baseline protections across industries,” Obama said. He signaled that the bill will limit companies' ability to collect data from consumers without their consent. ...
  • BabyBus Suspended From Google Play After FTC Warns Of Children's Privacy Violations

    The popular BabyBus apps appear to violate children's privacy laws, the Federal Trade Commission warns in a letter to the Chinese-based developer of the apps. “Several of your apps appear to collect precise geolocation information that is transmitted to third parties, including advertising networks and/or analytics companies,” Maneesha Mithal, associate ...
  • Judge Pauses Dispute Between Google And Miss. AG

    Google won't have to face any potential lawsuits by Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood until at least next year, under an order issued on Monday by U.S. District Court Judge Henry Wingate in Jackson, Miss. Wingate said in the order that he was pausing all proceedings in the dispute between ...
  • Mississippi Attorney General Seeks Temporary Truce With Google

    Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood said on Friday that he wants to pause an escalating dispute with Google regarding the company's search results. “I am calling a time out, so that cooler heads may prevail,” he said in a statement issued on Friday. Hood's statement came several hours after Google ...
  • Google Seeks Restraining Order Against Mississippi Attorney General

    Google on Friday asked a federal judge to prohibit Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood from following through on a threat to sue the company for enabling Web users to access “illegal” content. Google also is asking for an injunction prohibiting Hood from enforcing a subpoena demanding information relating to outside ...
  • Deutsch L.A. Settles FTC Charges That Employees Posed As Consumers On Twitter

    Deutsch L.A. engaged in a deceptive practice with an ad campaign that involved asking employees to promote Sony's PlayStation Vita on Twitter, the Federal Trade Commission alleged in a complaint unveiled on Tuesday. The resulting Twitter posts, which ran in 2012 and carried the hashtag #gamechanger, allegedly didn't indicate they ...
  • Aereo Declares Bankruptcy

    Online video distributor Aereo, which suspended operations three days after its Supreme Court defeat in June, said on Friday that it filed for bankrputcy. CEO Chet Kanojia says in a post on the company's blog that the move “will permit Aereo to maximize the value of its business and assets ...
  • Tom Noble Moves From BMW Australia To Oversee Mini U.S.A. Marketing .

    Mini U.S.A. has tapped Tom Noble, a marketer at BMW Australia, as department head, Mini Brand Communications. Noble, who will handle all brand positioning duties for Mini in the U.S. at the company's U.S. headquarters in Woodcliff Lake, N.J., replaces Tom Salkowsky, who was shifted overseas to be department head, ...
  • Sources: Steve Shannon Out As Top Hyundai Motor America Marketer

    Sources close to the company say Steve Shannon, VP marketing, is departing Hyundai Motor America. No confirmation from HMA or Shannon just yet. The General Motors alumnus, who tied up his 25 years at GM as marketing chief at Cadillac, was hired by the Orange Country, CA-based marketer in 2011. ...
>> Raw Archives