4A's And ANA Play Blame Game Over Dearth of Agency Talent

There's a heated debate going on between 4A's President Nancy Hill and Association of National Advertisers' Bob Liodice. After Hill penned a piece for CMO Today on why ad agencies are starved for talent in which she argued that agency pay is much lower -- particularly for entry-level positions, because clients don't pay enough -- than other industries, particularly tech, Liodice shot back, claiming it's the inefficient agency business model that's causing the problem. Hill writes: "Extended payment terms, unreasonable indemnification clauses, incentive plans that don’t incentivize, FTE negotiations on hours in a year all add up to a system that is broken." Liodice counters, saying agencies don't do enough to recruit the right people and, once they do, they don't offer the necessary training to retain that talent. Liodice also points out that the estimated sales and earnings growth of agencies is far more robust than that of brands, prompting one to wonder why agencies -- which appear to be financially healthy -- can't pay more for talent.

In case you were wondering, there are four types of digital agencies. At least according to Propane Studio CEO Neil Chaudart, who has taken it upon himself to categorize digital agencies for us. First, he says there's the "digital campaign agency" -- which is basically just a traditional agency that comes up with big, emotionally moving ideas. He explains: "Digital campaign agencies push these ideas out to all digital channels with the intention of luring users back to a central hub or destination: It's the 'big idea' that hooks them in." Next is the "integrated marketing digital agency" -- which is less about developing the big idea and more about tactics such as SEO, SEM, mobile, email and other executions designed to drive traffic to a particular destination by using data, analytics and marketing automation platforms. Third is the "digital solutions agency" which goes beyond the big idea and gets down and dirty with the development of CMS systems, sales portals, inventory management and custom software development with a marketing focus. And finally, there's the "DX agency" -- which is all about creating that pervasive aura of customer experience "and utilizes human psychology to create solutions that, when combined, activate a strong, steady pull towards the brand." Sort of like a cultish religion, if there were such a thing in the ad agency world.

Content marketing is all the rage now, right? Everyone's doing it. Everyone has something to say about it. And everyone wants to provide it as a service. Even media agencies. You know, those folks who take deep dives into data in order to decide where the ads should go? Yeah -- not too a big a leap. At least according to Starcom UK MediaVest Group Co-Chief Executive Steve Parker who argues in MediaWeek that media agencies are, in fact, perfectly capable of doing content marketing. Parker argues that the role of media has always been about delivering the right content to the right person in the right context. Furthermore, he adds: "While everyone else has been debating who owns content marketing, we have been building a team of more than 60 diverse specialists who use data to understand what content a consumer wants and take responsibility for creating, curating, delivering and optimizing that experience." Hmm, sounds quite logical to me.

Boston-based PJA Advertising and education organization College Bound Dorchester is out with 3 Syllable Boston, a game that asks players to solve 20 puzzles to see how well they know Boston. Players are asked questions about where the Boston Marathon ends, where the city parties on July 4th, Fenway Park trivia and more. But the catch is that all the answers are just three syllables long. Which sort of helps with the guessing. It's all to "promote fun, optimism and goodwill citywide.”
Recommend (3) Print RSS
1 comment about "4A's And ANA Play Blame Game Over Dearth of Agency Talent".
  1. Tom Messner from BONACCOLTA MESSNER , August 15, 2014 at 7:27 a.m.
    Mr. Liodice makes points that are demonstrable if true. The ANA members can all take their advertising in-house and see if Mr. Liodice's propositions are valid against the mirror of reality
  • This Guy Argues Doing Crowdsource Work Could Land You Your Dream Agency Job

    Asad Khan, Founder and CEO of creative crowdsourcing platform CopyShoppy, thinks crowdsourcing is awesome. And why wouldn't he? After all, that's what his company does. Well, he's out with a five-point argument entitled 5 Myths About Crowdsourcing Creative Work that explains why there's nothing wrong with the advertising community embracing ...
  • Michael Roth: If It Were Up to Martin Sorrell, There Would be One Holding Company

    So Dentsu would like to make it known that it's not looking to make acquisitions in the digital space. Hmm. Of the mindset, Dentsu Aegis Network Chairman Tim Andree, speaking at the annual Morgan Stanley Technology, Media and Telecoms Conference in Barcelona, said: "Acquisitions are not a strategy in and ...
  • Are Ad Agency Employees the Biggest "Empty Labor" Slackers?

    Well, well, well. Is an ad agency one of the places where workers waste the most amount of time engaging in "empty labor"? In a new book, Lund University Sociologist Roland Paulsen examines the notion of empty labor interviewing people from various industries. Paulsen found, on average, that employees across ...
  • President Obama Surprises Australian Ad Man By Using His 29-Year-Old Tagline In Speech

    Australian ad man Tim Bond is happy. Really, really happy. In 1985 Bond was working for D'Arcy MacManus and Masius and was asked to come up with a tagline for Queensland. He thought about the task for ten weeks. And out came "Beautiful one day, perfect the next." It became ...
  • This Creative Brief Was Delivered With Oculus Rift and A Treadmill

    Talk about an all-inclusive, complete brief! As part of its annual Creative Press Challenge, Dutch newspaper Persgroep briefed 110 creatives on the Iranian refugee situation for the charity group UAF by immersing them in the very issue they would be assigned to tackle. How? By using the virtual reality technology ...
  • Leo Burnett Employees Do Shots And Slap Each Other In The Face To Improve Creativity

    What's an ad agency to do when it's had enough bad ideas and it simply can't take it any longer? It invites their employees to do shots and slap each other in the face, of course! As part of its participation in Strategy Magazine's Agency of the Year event in ...
  • GSD&M Leads Movember Agency Challenge With Crazy Spanish Telenovela

    Doing its part for Movember, GSD&M -- along with its MoPack Movember team -- is helping to spread the word about men's health with the launch of...wait for it...a Spanish telenovela. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense, right? But, hey, GSD&M is an ad agency and ad agencies just ...
  • Fallon 'Winternship' Program to Clothe, House, Transport, Entertain 8 Lucky Interns

    Well, of course they are! After all, who'd want to intern at an agency in freezing cold Minnesota when they could work in the warm confines of Manhattan? Oh, wait. Anyway, Fallon Minneapolis has launched an intern program called Wintern. In order to lure interns into the program, the agency ...
  • Leo Burnett Tops List of Adoption-Friendly Workplaces

    Well, there's a list for everything, right? Why not one for the best workplaces with adoption-friendly policies? Yeah, why not? Well the Dave Thomas Foundation for Adoption has awarded Leo Burnett the top spot on its 2014 list of the top adoption-friendly workplaces in advertising, marketing and public relations followed ...
  • Mindshare Has All the Answers to Your Millennial Questions

    Anything and everything you ever wanted to know about Millennials. WPP media shop Mindshare North America is out with new research. Badge Brands and the New Millennial Identity, takes a look at the importance of intelligence and friendship to the Millennial generation -- and how brands can capitalize on Millennials ...
>> MAD Archives