Court Rules For Blogger In Subpoena Dispute
Bloggers often anticipate that provocative items will spark comments from readers. But for Kathleen Seidel, a post on her blog, neurodiversity.com, prompted a lawyer to serve her with a subpoena demanding everything from her bank records to tax returns to copies of all correspondence related to any issue on her Web site.The New Hampshire blogger fought back, asking a judge to quash the subpoena. This week, a federal district court agreed with Seidel and not only granted her request, but also ruled that the lawyer who attempted to subpoena Seidel must defend himself against potential sanctions for issuing the "burdensome" document.
The ruling is seen boosting the ability of citizen journalists and other online publishers to stand up to critics who try to silence them by issuing subpoenas or engaging in other legal maneuvers. "It's very good news for individuals who blog on controversial topics," said David Ardia, director of Harvard's Citizen Media Law Project. Ardia added that bloggers faced with subpoenas often feel compelled to either turn over the information or "willingly shut down their criticism in an effort to avoid a legal threat."
The case stemmed from a post Seidel wrote on March 24. In that post, she wrote about a recent legal decision regarding thimerosal in vaccines, which some people suspect causes autism and other disorders. She also blogged about Clifford Shoemaker, a prominent lawyer for plaintiffs in cases involving injuries from vaccines, and how much he was awarded in attorney's fees and costs.
Seidel alleged that shortly after the post went live, she received a subpoena from Shoemaker, who is currently representing Lisa and Seth Sykes in a lawsuit in federal court in Virginia against Bayer Corporation. The Sykes allege that their son developed autism as a result of exposure in utero to mercury.
The broad subpoena demanded a host of information from Seidel, including tax returns, LexisNexis records and copies of communications with a wide range of groups or individuals ranging from the federal government to editorial boards to journals.
She argued that she was entitled to the same privilege as traditional journalists in her state, where judges have held that reporters have protection for newsgathering activities.
"Although I am unaffiliated with a traditional news organization," she wrote, "I am a de facto citizen-journalist regularly engaged in the public dissemination of news and information, and the promotion of discourse and advocacy regarding issues of national importance."
The court didn't give any reasons for quashing the subpoena, but ordered Shoemaker to show why he shouldn't be sanctioned for violating a rule to avoid "burdensome subpoenas."
Recent Online Media Daily Articles
-
Coca-Cola Loses Bid To Dismiss Text-Spam Case May 24, 5:41 p.m.
Consumers can proceed with a lawsuit against Coca-Cola for allegedly sending them unwanted SMS messages, a ... -
Disaster Ready: Google Maps Model Quickly Adjusts To Events May 24, 5:29 p.m.
The four-lane bridge in Washington state that partially collapsed Thursday into the Skagit River was removed ... -
Pandora Beats Rev Estimates, Adds Subscribers May 24, 5:01 p.m.
Online radio service Pandora on Thursday reported that revenue rose 55% in the first quarter to $126 ... -
Real-Time Web Turns Consumers Into Impulse Buyers May 24, 4:37 p.m.
Video, mobile, social, and better search capabilities continue to make it easy for consumers to buy ... -
Mugnier Shares M&C Saatchi's Mobile Approach May 24, 4:32 p.m.
M&C Saatchi Mobile was formed three years ago through the acquisition of mobile marketing agency Inside ... -
Yahoo Search Experiments With New Look May 23, 6:30 p.m.
Yahoo Search has been experimenting with colors, features and layouts, as the company tries to determine ... -
Path Seeks Dismissal Of Wireless-Spam Case May 23, 5:07 p.m.
Mobile social network Path is asking a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit alleging that the ... -
Amazon Appstore Goes Global May 23, 4:59 p.m.
Amazon may have been late to the app store game, but that hasn’t stopped it from ... -
Data Is Springboard For Product Development May 23, 4:44 p.m.
iProspect named Ben Wood to global president Thursday; he's tasked with growing the company's network and ... -
Vice, Twitter Partner For Mobile Show May 23, 2:14 p.m.
Simultaneously expanding its video and social strategy, Vice on Thursday unveiled #dailyvice -- a daily show ...
Be the first to comment on "Court Rules For Blogger In Subpoena Dispute "
Leave a Comment