Commentary
Canceled Before Its Time: There Goes Honey Boo Boo
- by Adam Buckman , Featured Columnist, October 27, 2014
At least we now know the limits of what’s tolerable on reality TV now that TLC has canceled “Here Comes Honey Boo Boo” after it came to light that Mama
June was consorting with a convicted child molester.
The man -- Mark Anthony McDaniel -- was convicted in Georgia in 2004 of aggravated child molestation. And it is also being suggested that his victim may have been one of Mama June Thompson’s daughters -- although reportedly not Alana, aka Honey Boo Boo.
TLC quickly severed its ties with Honey Boo Boo and her family last week seemingly within hours after the news broke on TMZ.com that June was possibly dating this guy.
It was a very unusual cancellation -- among other reasons, because the entire new season had apparently been filmed and was ready to go. Perhaps this guy McDaniel is actually in the episodes, which would make for a pretty good reason not to air them.
advertisement
advertisement
However, TLC isn’t saying whether or not he was a participant in the episodes. The only peep from TLC was this official statement: “TLC has cancelled the series HERE COMES HONEY BOO BOO and ended all activities around the series, effective immediately. Supporting the health and welfare of these remarkable children is our only priority. TLC is faithfully committed to the children’s ongoing comfort and well-being.”
The statement raises (but does not answer) the question of how canceling the show supports the “health and welfare” of Alana and her siblings or demonstrates TLC’s commitment “to the children’s ongoing comfort and well-being.” Perhaps TLC has set up some kind of counseling or after-care for this family. TLC’s statement doesn’t indicate anything like that, however. Instead, the statement makes it look more like TLC is just washing its corporate hands of this Thompson family and that’s it.
And so “Here Comes Honey Boo Boo” is over, cancelled before its time, for one of the most unusual reasons in the annals of TV-show cancellations. It lasted about two years, from August 2012 to August 2014 -- four seasons comprising a total of 52 episodes.
For a time, it was the most talked-about show on television, particularly in the summer of 2012 when it launched its first season after being spun off from TLC’s icky kiddie-pageant series “Toddlers & Tiara.”
Back then, Honey Boo Boo was a pop culture phenomenon -- the talk of talk shows and a guest on some of them. For example, who can forget her crucial endorsement of President Obama in his bid to be re-elected when she appeared on “Jimmy Kimmel Live” in October 2012? In addition to endorsing the president, Alana, then 7, spent the bulk of her segment with Kimmel ignoring his questions, fidgeting and staring into space. At one point, while mom June looked on, Alana plunged her hand into Kimmel’s water glass for no apparent reason. She also told Kimmel she had never heard of Mitt Romney -- a blow to the Romney campaign from which it never recovered.
The sordid way that “Here Comes Honey Boo Boo” has ended is sad, particularly if June really is carrying on with a man who should not be anywhere near her family. Before this, the only story I can recall in which someone close to the Thompson family had a run-in with the law was the arrest in Georgia in November 2012 of Tony Lindsay, described alternately as a “cousin” or just a “family friend.”
He was charged with reckless behavior for an incident in which he donned a gorilla suit and then pretended to leap into oncoming traffic, jarring motorists and nearly causing a series of accidents. A few months later, June herself banned “cousin” Tony from the show. “TV’s changed that family,” cousin Tony said at the time.
Perhaps TV did change the Thompsons. In the end, the one I feel sorry for is Honey Boo Boo. She didn’t do anything, but due to circumstances beyond her control, she has lost her TV show -- which means that for now, Alana “Honey Boo Boo” Thompson is washed up as a TV star at age 9.
June says he dated the clown quite some time ago, not now. If the network cared about the welfare of those kids then why didn't they pay for surgery to correct the birth defect of June's granddaughter two years ago? Why didn't they really push for that surgery? If they care about the kids then how about moving them away from the unprotected freight train tracks? It's a long list of questions.
The only surprise is that Jeff Zucker, Turner and CNN didn't seize the opportunity offered by TLC (What does TLC really stand for?) to make Honey Boo Boo a primetime news anchor with a weekly series on enlightened child care. Just think of how much CNN could broaden its ever declining audience. (Are there any viewers left?) With Honey Boo Boo, CNN could perhaps be repositioned as the Children's Nihilistic Network (CNN). Somebody's Gotta Do It!
I’ve never been a fan of this show, but it looks like the main point is that the real star of the show here is Honey Boo Boo, and nobody else. Sure other people make up part of the cast, and how the show plays out overall, but certain actions from the cast seemed to have affected the show even more. Whereas Honey Boo Boo is the one that had to pay for the cast’s actions, and end up with no show. Though she is still young, with this out in the open, she could have a bad reputation at such a young age, not necessarily because of her actions, but the actions of those around her.
I think that is the only problem of being a child and famous, your actions are controlled and handled in a way that any person would handle a child, but if you are that young and have your own show, then you have no control over what can happen, or what can be changed or covered up, in order to keep the show from canceling. We see many accusations made from other shows where only adult actors are the main characters, and those stories get covered up really easily, it seems a bit unfair that they can’t do the same with Honey Boo Boo’s show. Like I said, I’ve never been such a big fan of the show, but to me it seems unfair that she has to go through this and pay for what other do.