Is Attribution Like Religion?

What do you believe?

Analytics and attribution in advertising are similar to religion.  You have to believe in one approach based on the result of how it makes you feel, and you stick with it for a long time.  Maybe somewhere along the way you make a switch, but not without much consternation and debate.  For an attribution model to work, you have to have faith.

Last week I moderated a panel on this topic where this analogy resonated with me.  Many advertisers use many different models for attribution, from media-mix models to last click, from weighted averages based on previous experience to massively complex algorithms.  

The only thing consistent for these models is, they all have flaws because they are trying to measure human behavior, which is ultimately unpredictable.

To that end, you have to pick an approach and stick with it because what you want is to measure trends over a period of time.  If you can count on the consistent inconsistency in your model, then you can be effective in your analytics!



The goal is to understand the model’s flaws, account for them, and ensure they are consistently wrong in the same place.  If you do this, you can look at the trend over time.  

What doesn’t make any sense is testing out new models of attribution on a regular basis.  

The dirty little secret is that if you work the numbers enough, you can get them to say whatever you want them to say.  Numbers are malleable in one-off instances.  Trends are not malleable.  

The trend of improvement over time and a trend that correlates to increased sales results in an effective campaign.  You can accept fluidity as long as it is over a long period of time.

My advice is to identify a model and stick with it for at least a year, and preferably for two to three.  At one year, you might start to see some trends and can determine if those trends are in line with your sales numbers.  Over a two-to-three-year period, you can absolutely identify connections.
During that panel last week, one of the panelists made a great comment: Being data-driven is not the same as being data-informed.  Being data-driven means you rely very heavily on the numbers to make your decisions.  Being data-informed means you read the numbers, but you still have the choice to ignore them and go with your gut.  

If you have the right analytics model in place, you are very likely to know that the numbers are what they tell you, but you will never be afraid to make the final decision based on what your instincts are telling you.

If the model is accurate (enough), then your decision will either pay out or prove wrong quickly, and the trend line of your results will tell you this.  It’s about belief.  Do you believe in your instincts — and are there data points to support your ideas?

3 comments about "Is Attribution Like Religion?".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Ed Papazian from Media Dynamics Inc, August 2, 2017 at 2:52 p.m.

    Good one, Cory. I would say that one should take even more time using any predictive model that seems to work---like ten years or longer--- so as to be able to identify and explain abberations and gain a deeper understanding by following the trends and the ability of the model to react to them. I would add, however, that, in my experience, many advertisers stick doggedly with a single model---even when the marketing or media situation has changed---and this clouds their perspectives or ability to react more flexibly. Accordingly, the best path may be to use two or more alternative data and assumption models, run in parallel with the old, tried and, hopefully, true model. This takes more time and effort but it seems to be an option that many advertisers might consider---even those that pinch pennies when it comes to this kind of thing.

  2. Paula Lynn from Who Else Unlimited, August 2, 2017 at 7:14 p.m.

    Is attribution the effects of religion ?

  3. Gail King from Marketing Evolution , August 2, 2017 at 10:50 p.m.

    I agree 100% as long as the attribution partner is an unbiased 3rd party.

Next story loading loading..