Commentary

What Marketers Can Learn From MoviePass' Struggle

MoviePass: the company that wants to provide a movie ticket subscription package for $10 a month, making an overpriced industry affordable. The company has generated a lot of buzz in the last few months, but a lot of that talk has been negative.

MoviePass is certainly trying to disrupt the film industry, but perhaps it took on more than it could handle. Its adversarial stance certainly helped the company get consumers’ attention, but it also may have set MoviePass up for a fall.

MoviePass has already made a huge impact on the film industry, amassing more than 2 million subscribers. Consumer data suggests the company has been a major factor in luring people back to the cinema.

The aggressive marketing tactics that MoviePass took in its early days to get the word out about its product worked, appearing  to have played a factor in a simultaneous spike in conversation about going to the movies.

Brand recognition is key goal in the early stages of any company, so by launching itself into the public eye through high profile features in magazines, advertisements, and social media, it was able to disrupt the entire industry.

advertisement

advertisement

Sounds like a big win for MoviePass, right? Well, as MoviePass has become more talked-about, its frequent changes and bold promises have hurt its consumer perception.

In the past few months, MoviePass’ reputation has been increasingly volatile, as a slew of new policies have angered its customer base. For the last several months, the company has seemed to announce changes to its business model every week.

MoviePass has had a few marketing wins, though -- with moves like a reintroduction to unlimited movies -- but short-lived policy changes create short-lived positive sentiment. Overall, consumer sentiment has been on the decline, with an all-time low of only 25% favorability.

In several instances, MoviePass has been able to recover the brand’s positive sentiment, but its approach has also proven problematic. Often, the company will respond to negative sentiment by announcing new policy changes. However, just as quickly, sentiment has dropped again as consumers lose faith in these promises.

Also, when looking major news and entertainment publications since August 2017, many reports focus on skepticism about MoviePass’s business model, noting that it couldn’t possibly be profitable. And it’s true, MoviePass burns over $20 million in cash a month, given that if a customer in a major city goes to one movie per month, the company is already in the red.

But a change in subscription costs only adds to the perception that MoviePass doesn’t understand its target audience, and that further leads to the skepticism of its business model. One of the best ways to counteract that would be to find consistency. In a perfect world, it would go back to what people got excited about in the first place, which would be the movie-a-day plan, but at this point, any consistency would be helpful.

As MoviePass tries to reinvent the wheel, the best solution is to listen to its customers and bring back what they were initially excited about: unlimited movies. The unlimited promise that hasn’t been its model for some time still remains a main topic, amid talk of people canceling their subscription and poor customer service.

With all these recent changes, many fear MoviePass is in turmoil and  may not last long enough to see its industry innovation come to fruition.

The MoviePass model may still be the future. Demand is certainly high, and the increasingly pricey industry has been in need of a shakeup for a long time coming. The only existing question is whether or not it will be the company that finds success, or whether it will meet its point of no return while another player steps up.

4 comments about "What Marketers Can Learn From MoviePass' Struggle".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Daniel Olson from The Loyalty Consultants, September 13, 2018 at 1:27 p.m.

    Great article Lou. This scenario is like the old joke, "We lose money on every transaction but we will make it up in volume!". The real solution here is that they need to understand that they have two miilion users and all their behavioral data. In the movie business the pressure to win in the first two weekends is enormous, having lost a ton profit that used to be delivered in the DVD sales, forces a need to win big in the first release. Moviepass could offset their loss by monetizing their marketing engine to help movie makers promote presell the first weekend. Much the way Vegas used to offset the cost of hotels and food just to have people play the games. So in reality thier business model is not really to provide the undoable but to provide insights into creating better profits for the studios, which would bring us better movies, which would drive more movie goers to the theaters which would give them more insight. 

    Dan Olson

  2. Ronald Kurtz from American Affluence Research Center, September 13, 2018 at 1:59 p.m.

    As a former MoviePass subscriber and a C-level executive in various hospitality and service industries, I believe the MoviePass management was probably the most inept executives I have ever observed. 

    They did not plan and/or execute their business model properly (as though they did not fully undertand the industry). They had continuing technical problems with their app and the interface with the theatres that made them useless to their subscribers at times. This was accompanied by occasional procedural changes that added to the frustration of subscribers.

    Finally, they had no real customer service function to help subscribers with the problems they were experienceing. It was as if they were putting up fences to avoid dealing with unhappy subscribers. 

    If they are able to remain in business (though I do have friends who have hung in with them) it will be a miracle.

  3. Jeff Ferguson from Amplitude Digital, September 13, 2018 at 3:28 p.m.

    Unfortunately, it’s a great idea... just not for them. The whole model is based on the premise that a large number of people would pay for the service without actually using the service. However, it’s a great idea that too many customers are actually using, so unless MoviePass worked out deals with theaters to get discounted ticket prices, even the first use each month puts them in the red. 

    Meanwhile, AMC has launched their own version at twice the price and some limits (three tickets a week) knowing that people will make it up in concession sales, a theater’s most profitable area. 

  4. Robert Marich from MarketingMovies.net, September 14, 2018 at 2:49 p.m.

    This column doesn't understand the driving force behind MoviePass, which was not a sustanable business. It was a stock market play to run up its subscriber count to impress unsophisticated retail investors, who bought stock on the premise I-like-the-product. Those retail investors purchased its stock on emotion. If MoviePass was built to last, it would have been priced $25 from the beginning. Going forward, MoviePass faces stiff competition and diverted financal resources to an uphill march into filmmaking. Unfortunately when competition was modest, it didn't establish lasting roots.

Next story loading loading..

Discover Our Publications