Facebook's Latest Trick: Replacing Users' Email Addresses

In the latest in a long string of questionable moves, Facebook has replaced users' old email addresses with new Facebook addresses.

This means that when you click on a user's contact information in hopes of sending the person a private email, you no longer see the Gmail, AOL, Yahoo or other email address that the person intended for you to see. Instead, you see an email address that was created and controlled by the social networking service.

Users can go into their settings and undo Facebook's change -- if they know about it. But many people don't have any idea (yet) that the company made the revision; Facebook certainly didn't do anything to publicize it.

In fact, the only reason that the shift came to attention is because a sharp-eyed blogger realized over the weekend what had happened and alerted followers to the move. "Facebook silently inserted themselves into the path of formerly-direct unencrypted communications from people who want to email me," he wrote. "What on earth do they think they are playing at?"

That post was picked up today by some tech journalists, who spread news of Facebook's latest maneuver. Facebook's email grab clearly irritated those users who learned of it -- and with good reason. If nothing else, people who don't want their messages going to Facebook inboxes must take time out of their day to restore their old settings.

The move also raises questions about whether the company is violating the terms of its consent decree with the Federal Trade Commission. That order requires Facebook to obtain users' explicit opt-in consent before overriding their privacy preferences.

Privacy advocates and Facebook can probably make arguments both ways on that point. On one hand, Facebook isn't revealing any additional information about people; in some ways, the company is giving them more privacy by hiding their outside email addresses. On the other hand, Facebook arguably is overriding users' expressed privacy preferences by hiding the very email addresses users wanted to share.

Regardless, the email switch isn't the first time Facebook has changed its service without adequate notice to users. There was the 2007 Beacon program, which spread news about people's ecommerce activity with their friends; the company is still in litigation over that fiasco. Two years later, the company had another privacy debacle when it revised users' default settings so that information that had previously been private was now public. That change resulted in the company's settlement with the FTC.

Hopefully Facebook will retreat from this latest half-baked idea as soon as possible.

Tags: facebook, privacy
Recommend (5)
3 comments about "Facebook's Latest Trick: Replacing Users' Email Addresses".
  1. Latease Rikard from LMR Publishing , June 26, 2012 at 7:34 a.m.
    Facebook is starting to irritate me little by little.
  2. David Hawthorne from HCI LearningWorks , June 26, 2012 at 10:45 a.m.
    The is the Letterman, "Is this anything?" moment we've been waiting for. We will soon here from FB users about how 'important' FB is to them. If people decide they don't like being captives, or monetized without compensation, then the belly flop of the IPO could become a stock that sinks like a rock.
  3. Robert Repas from Machine Design Magazine , June 26, 2012 at 11:08 a.m.
    As far as I can see, Facebook has just provided everyone with a Facebook email account. The original email address I submitted is still present and is marked as "primary" email. I see it nothing more than signing up for a service and having a free email account provided. But, according to FB, anything sent to that email account goes into your message area like any other message from another user. In other words, they just gave their advertisers (and spammers) another vector to send you crap.