Copyright Troll Grilled By Appeals Judges
It looks like the copyright troll Righthaven is facing an uphill battle in its bid to resurrect its lawsuits against bloggers.
Two years ago, Righthaven appeared out of nowhere and started suing small publishers and bloggers who reposted articles from the Las Vegas Review Journal and other newspapers.
The company, helmed by attorney Steven Gibson, brought nearly 300 lawsuits -- including cases against a woman who blogged about cats, a 20-year-old man suffering from autism as well as severe diabetes, and a source who proudly reposted an article based on his research -- before it was shut down by trial judges.
The main reason why Righthaven's scheme unraveled was fairly technical: It never obtained all of the rights to the articles -- especially the right to license them to other publications.
If the Las Vegas Review-Journal had hired a law firm to bring copyright lawsuits, the cases might not have been thrown out. But the newspaper didn't structure its deal that way. Instead, it tried to assign the right to sue to Righthaven while keeping the other rights to the articles -- an arrangement that the 9th Circuit condemned years ago, in a different case.
Once trial judges learned the details of Righthaven's arrangement with newspapers, the courts started throwing out Righthaven's lawsuits. Righthaven appealed to the 9th Circuit, where the company argued that its contract with newspapers was valid.
A three-judge panel heard arguments on Tuesday. They appeared unimpressed with Righthaven's argument, with one judge going so far as to call the company's contract with newspapers "too cute by half."
From the overall tone of the argument (an audio recording is available on the 9th Circuit's site), it seems that the judges are inclined to uphold the dismissals. If so, that's good news for the people sued by Righthaven, but it won't prevent other content owners from simply hiring attorneys to bring infringement cases against bloggers in the future.
Recent Daily Online Examiner Articles
-
NSA News Drives Consumers To Seek More Privacy Protection June 19, 5:30 p.m.
If nothing else, news about the National Security Agency's extensive surveillance activities seems to have left ...
-
BuzzFeed Slideshow Leads To Copyright Lawsuit June 18, 7:31 p.m.
BuzzFeed has been hit with a copyright infringement complaint that could have a significant impact on ...
-
Can Ad Networks And Advocates Close The Gap On Do-Not-Track? June 17, 7:54 p.m.
Will the World Wide Web Consortium's effort to forge online privacy standards come to naught? Some ...
-
Analyst: NSA Surveillance Will Raise Awareness About Big Data June 14, 6:18 p.m.
The National Security Agency's data collection from Web companies remains top of mind for analysts and ...
-
Ad Group Warns Of Possible Backlash From NSA Surveillance June 13, 6:42 p.m.
For almost one week now, the ad industry has been digesting the revelations that the National ...
-
Cable Companies Try To Prevent New Platforms From Gaining Foothold June 12, 6:45 p.m.
Cable companies and telecoms apparently are so spooked by the prospect of cord-cutting that they're now ...
-
Mozilla, Other Web Companies Lobby To Rein In NSA June 11, 6:50 p.m.
Search engine Duck Duck Go, browser developer Mozilla and social news site Reddit are among dozens ...
-
Will NSA Revelations Bring Added Privacy Pressure To Ad Biz? June 10, 5:57 p.m.
The recent revelations that tech companies are sharing information about users with the National Security Agency ...
-
Universities Garner Support In Battle Against Authors Guild June 7, 5:26 p.m.
A broad array of outside organizations is aligning themselves against the Authors Guild in its lawsuit ...
-
FCC Poised To Vote On Wireless Privacy Protections June 6, 6:38 p.m.
The Federal Communications Commission will vote at the end of this month about whether to issue ...
1 comment on "Copyright Troll Grilled By Appeals Judges".
Leave a Comment