You Don't Want Men

When I hear someone say, “we want to target men for our marketing campaign” or “we want men’s publications for our PR campaign,” that raises an immediate red flag to me as a marketer and an analyst. “Men” is a giant category, approximately 3.5 billion people, and the chances that your product, service, or announcement is going to resonate with all of them is exceptionally small. Campaigns that aim for “men” often fall far short of the target, at best wasting marketing dollars on people who don’t care about what you have to offer, and at worst offending portions of your audience.

You don’t want “men.” You want very specific categories of men. As a basic example, there is a giant gap in terms of culture and interests between straight men and gay men. There is a giant gap of preference between liberal men and conservative men, between Jewish men and Muslim men, between men from Boston, Massachusetts and men from Tallahassee, Florida. The question is, which subset of men do you want to reach?

If you’re not sure, chances are the reason you don’t know is that you haven’t done an assessment of the men in your audience. Fortunately, developing an understanding of your audience is much less difficult than it used to be. For example, look at Facebook’s new Audience Insights tool. Suppose you wanted to understand male marketers better. Choosing that in the tool would give you strong indicators of what else they’re interested in, data that you can use to guide everything from content creation to PR outreach to product features.

For example, the Facebook Audience Insights tool displays that all male marketers exhibit the following interests as their Top Categories:

  1. Community: Nike Football, Diesel Trucks For Sale
  2. Automotive: CaRiD.com
  3. Clothing: New Era Cap, Country Outfitter Mens
  4. Tools/Equipment: Craftsman
  5. Media/News/Publishing: Playboy, MAXIM Magazine
  6. Magazine: Sports Illustrated Swimsuit, Truckin’ Magazine, Smoking Rubber
  7. Outdoor Gear/Sporting Goods: Remington Arms Company, Bass Pro Shops, Oakley
  8. Video Game: Need for Speed
  9. Company: Irish Spring, X Games, Dick’s Sporting Goods, Monday Night Football
  10. Cars: Ram Trucks, Dodge

As an example of how drastically preferences can change/shift, below is the exact same dataset from the Audience Insights tool but with one twist: identifying gay male marketers.

  1. Government Organization: Reasons
  2. App: Scruff, Jack’d
  3. Shopping/Retail: Boy Next Door | Menswear
  4. Hotel: Island House Key West Gay Hotel & Resort
  5. Community: Gay Geeks, Gay And Fabulous, Out Military, Arthus & Nico, Underwear Society
  6. City: Engenho De Dentro, Rio De Janeiro; Brazil, Eagle, New Jersey
  7. Product/Service: Grindr
  8. Company: 4Boys Gear, UnderGear, PROHIBITEDfashion
  9. Personal Website: ADAM4ADAM.com
  10. Sports League: Sports Illustrated 4 Gays
  11. Website: Manhunt, The Gay Classifieds, Corbin Fisher, Queerty, The Underwear Expert
  12. Club: Krave Las Vegas

The dataset changes fairly radically. This is why persona development is so vital to your success. Define your personas very carefully. The more detailed you can be, the easier it will be to craft marketing plans and strategies around those personas.

Similar tools exist from companies like Google AdWords and even Twitter analytics for your followers, though they offer somewhat less flexibility.

The third thing you must do to reach men is to then craft your marketing campaigns to be exclusive. If you know who your audience is and what characteristics they exhibit, then create content, campaigns, ads, social media updates, etc. only for that audience. For example, if your data shows that single straight men ages 25-34 who are interested in marketing like the following:

  1. Clothing: Two In The Shirt, New Era Cap
  2. Interest: State Property
  3. Health/Beauty: Dove Men+Care
  4. Website: DatPiff
  5. Just For Fun: Method Man Fans
  6. Retail and Consumer Merchandise: Footaction
  7. TV Channel: NBA on TNT
  8. Entertainer: 2pac, Master P
  9. Wine/Spirits: Hennessy, Grey Goose Vodka, Bacardi
  10. Company: Irish Spring
  11. Movie: Scarface, Paid in Full, New Jack City, Belly, Juice, Half Baked
  12. Food/Beverages: Dos Equis, Heineken, Coors Light, Ciroc, Miller Lite, Kellogg’s Frosted Flakes
  13. Public Figure: Cherokee D’Ass, Mike Epps, Bruce Lee, Chris Farley
  14. News/Media: Official WorldStarHipHop

Then craft everything around them to the exclusion of others. For example, if you were going to write a casual summer cookout blog post, you’d want to reference Bacardi or Grey Goose, but probably not red wine. You’d want to set up pay per click ads targeting this crowd narrowly, filtered on as many interests and affiliations above as your ad platform would allow you to target. You’d want your landing pages to be themed consistent with this crowd; even little things like clip art or stock photography can matter for conveying a sense of alignment.

It’s ever so tempting for a marketer to want to shotgun blast their message to the widest audience possible. Resist that temptation: the more tailored you can make your message using digital audience analytics tools, the better it will resonate with your audience and get them to take the action you want them to take. Your audience will feel as though you are speaking directly to them and only them.

Tags: facebook, men
Recommend (2) Print RSS
1 comment about "You Don't Want Men".
  1. Karen Shiffert from Caregivers aide, LLC , July 3, 2014 at 2:26 p.m.
    Thank you for this explanation. I have tried to use FB Audience insights but never knew (and still don't completely understand) what is possible to sort out. I will try to absorb this and put it to use.