Net Neutrality Advocates Question Comcast Traffic Plan
Comcast said on Friday that it will deal with congestion on its network by slowing down the connections of the heaviest users, regardless of which applications they are using. The company intends to do so in near real-time, by deprioritizing traffic of Web users who have used a high amount of bandwidth in the previous 15-minute period.
Previously, Comcast managed traffic by slowing peer-to-peer visits--a strategy the FCC found unlawful for violating the principle that all lawful applications be treated equally.
While Comcast's new approach is protocol-neutral, advocates say it still raises concerns. One question posed by Public Knowledge is why Comcast still intends to impose bandwidth caps if it is managing congestion by slowing traffic nearly contemporaneously with high usage.
Last month, Comcast officially said it would impose bandwidth caps of 250 GB a month for consumer accounts.
Comcast spokeswoman Sena Fitzmaurice said the 250 GB cap is intended to curb excessive use, which can cause stress on the network without necessarily resulting in congestion.
Robb Topolski, chief technology consultant for net neutrality groups Free Press and Public Knowledge, said he was still analyzing Comcast's papers, but had some preliminary concerns related to Comcast's decision to base decisions about users on their activity in 15-minute increments.
"Comcast's new plan essentially gives consumers the right to 15 minutes worth of their Comcast subscription, after which they are entitled to no bandwidth but are allowed to forage for leftovers," Topolski said. "This is not what users expect from their Internet subscriptions, it's not what designers expect when developing products for the Internet, and it has not yet been approved by the IETF (Internet Engineering Task Force) for use on real users."
Recent Online Media Daily Articles
-
CIMM Issues Request For Data, Cross-Platform Metrics June 19, 9:29 a.m.
The Coalition for Innovative Media Measurement (CIMM) said it has issued a request for proposals involving ... -
Heads Or Tails: Facebook Grows A Long One, Surpasses 1 Million Advertisers June 19, 7:48 a.m.
Facebook has reached an important ad industry milestone, becoming one of the few mega platforms to ... -
Consumer Action: Most Web Users Want Control Over Tracking June 18, 8:20 p.m.
Most Web users have expectations about privacy that appear to be at odds with current practices ... -
Affiliate Channels Attract Global Buying, Tailored Marketing Programs June 18, 5:54 p.m.
The Internet continues to make the world smaller for affiliate marketers, but there are physical challenges ... -
Microsoft Rolls Out Ad Pano, Mobile Ad Format June 18, 3:03 p.m.
With the help of the broader ad industry, Microsoft this week is rolling out a mobile ... -
Kiip Debuts Self-Serve Option For Advertisers June 18, 2:23 p.m.
Mobile rewards network Kiip has added a self-serve option for advertisers aimed at attracting more small- and medium-sized ... -
Mindshare Taps Elkins As Managing Director, Digital, West Coast June 18, 1:51 p.m.
Mindshare, part of WPP's GroupM, has tapped digital marketing veteran Amy Elkins to be managing director, ... -
Blogging Stake: WPP Invests In Muzy June 18, 9:12 a.m.
WPP has taken a stake in Muzy Inc., an early-stage micro-blogging service focused on mobile content ... -
MSN, Newsy Partnership To Debut June 18, 7:40 a.m.
MSN on Tuesday is expected to announce a partnership with mobile-focused video news network Newsy. Similar to ... -
ZO Shaves Global Ad Outlook: Says Internet, Especially Mobile, Will Be Greatest Growth Engines June 18, 7:34 a.m.
The global ad economy now is expected to expand only 3.5% this year, according to the ...
Be the first to comment on "Net Neutrality Advocates Question Comcast Traffic Plan"
Leave a Comment