A Message From Christchurch On The Value Of User-Generated Content

by Kaila Colbin, Mar 18, 2011, 12:00 PM

• Comment
• Recommend (2)
• Tweet
• 

Here is a sample of the stories I have been told in my quake-stricken home city of Christchurch:

A friend gave mouth-to-mouth to a fallen man, through blood and bone and crushed teeth. The man died. Another, racing down the hill in his car to get to his young son at school, being blocked by rockfall, getting on a bike, arriving marginally further, ditching the bike, running, rounding the corner, seeing the collapsed cliff that had buried the back half of the school. The son is alive.

A third, trapped on the first floor of a building with 25 students, being rescued by a nameless window cleaner who smashed the window and accompanied every person down his ladder, guiding their every step until everyone came out safe.

Here is a taste of what you have to deal with in the aftermath of an earthquake:

You have no power. This means your TV doesn't work, and neither does your Internet or your cordless phone. You can't recharge your cell phone, and you've used up all the batteries frantically trying to get through to your loved ones on the overloaded network. This, of course, is assuming you have your phone and didn't leave it behind, along with your wallet and your laptop, in the frenzied scramble to get out alive while the walls of your building collapsed around you. You have no water to drink, and none to flush the toilet, so you dig holes in the backyard. You may have lost your car, your office, your job, your home, your friend, your spouse. You have to surmount innumerable additional hurdles, deal with insurance companies and government agencies, itemize your destruction and fill out your paperwork: administrative and logistical distractions that require effort and attention just when you are at your lowest in terms of emotional and psychological resources.

Here is some of what you need in the event of a natural disaster:

You need to know your loved ones are alive and OK. You need to know where to get the water, which roads are open, whether any supermarkets are functioning, whether there is additional danger, where the nearest porta-potty is located, where you can get gas for the car. You need to know whether others' experience is better or worse than yours, who needs what kind of help, who is around to help you, and who is just around so you don't feel so desperately alone, so mortally terrified, and so full of grief and uncertainty.

And here is what user-generated content does for you:

It helps you find your loved ones. It tells you where the water is and which supermarkets are functioning. It connects you with those around you, whether they need help, can help you, or neither. If you happen to be overseas when disaster strikes at home, it helps you understand what is happening on the ground, not from a media perspective, but from the perspective of your neighbors, the people who are living and breathing this event, who will be picking up the pieces for years after the CNN and BBC cameras have left, who will have to rely on each other when the world's attention and sympathies inevitably refocus on the next disaster elsewhere.

In a disaster, UGC is not here for your entertainment. It is not competing with network news for ad dollars. It does not care whether you think it should be pitted against the professionals for a journalism award. It is a way for people experiencing the most significant event of their lives to bear witness, to cry out their pain and their suffering and their need, to connect with people close by who are sharing the experience and with people far away who, but for their voices, might mistake these events for a blockbuster movie filmed on a sound stage. No human can fail to be moved by the horrific tragedy of Japan, made so real by the user-generated content coming from that ravaged coastline -- its very lack of professionalism making it so abundantly clear that there is no difference at all between us and them. In these turbulent times, we cannot afford to distance ourselves from the humanity at the other end of the camera, and from the reality that there but for the grace go we.

I'm grateful for your user-generated content, on Twitter or in the comments. Stay safe out there.

• Comment
• Recommend (2)
• Tweet
• 

0 comments on "A Message From Christchurch On The Value Of User-Generated Content".

1. Douglas Ferguson from College of Charleston
   

   commented on: March 18, 2011 at 12:17 p.m.

   I already have a flashlight and a radio that operate with a hand-crank, so it is possible to recharge batteries for cellphones. Sears, for example, sells a hand-crank battery charger, so maybe such an item (or a competing product) would make a welcome under $25 gift on the next occasion you cannot think of what to get someone. I found one on Amazon, too.

2. Robin Hafitz from open mind strategy
   

   commented on: March 18, 2011 at 12:57 p.m.

   How powerfully and thoughtfully conveyed. Thank you.

3. Tricia Murdy from MB
   

   commented on: March 18, 2011 at 1 p.m.

   So well written & full of emotion. It was great!

4. Rita Munoz from EMS
   

   commented on: March 18, 2011 at 1:39 p.m.

   Really well written and powerful. UGC is exactly what is needed in the wake of a disaster. My heart goes out to all those suffering.

5. Kelli Burns from USf
   

   commented on: March 18, 2011 at 1:56 p.m.

   I definitely agree with the power of UGC in times of great tragedy. We have seen this before--Hurricane Katrina comes to mind. What about the challenges of creating or accessing UGC when you have no computer (or no electricity to power your computer), no cellphone (or a dead battery), no Internet connection, etc? Messages might be able to get to those outside the situation from a handful of people who are lucky enough to have access, but for those who most need this information, you might not be so lucky.

6. Kaila Colbin from Missing Link
   

   commented on: March 18, 2011 at 3:37 p.m.

   Thank you so much for your kind comments, and Douglas for your practical one! And Kelli, you're so right; often the least connected people are the ones who need help the most.

7. Paula Lynn from Who Else Unlimited
   

   commented on: April 15, 2011 at 12:26 p.m.

   So ads on the twit will not help and take up precious battery power? Is it past time to be concerned with people who time suck with their own and hollywood gobbelty-gook ? Would you pay for the service if it looses so much money it ceases to exist? What would you pay? My money is on you and helping those in need.

Leave a Comment