Commentary

Privacy Worries: Politicians Collect Our Data-Then Can Sell It

Efforts to drive primary voters to caucus sites or voting locations are in sprint mode, as we close in on the first primaries. The huge sets of voter data, ranging from email addresses to physical addresses and political affiliation, are of enormous value.

It is no coincidence that there has been increased scrutiny over privacy policies that rule the dissemination of campaign data. Data integrations have been central to creating voter profiles and integral to the programmatic targeting effort borrowed from commercial advertising.

In September 2015, the Online Trust Alliance took a look at the privacy policies for 23 presidential candidates, many of whom have already dropped out of the race.

Of those still around, the results of the study highlight troubling policies when it comes to protecting voter data.

advertisement

advertisement

The study gave 74% of the candidates’ Web sites (those still in the race at the time) a failing grade, given either “nonexistent or inadequate privacy policy disclosures.” Even more worrisome,“they reserve the right to liberally share or sell their donors and site visitors’ personally identifiable information.”

This includes phone numbers and addresses, but also more personal and potentially dangerous data, like passport numbers. Additionally, the privacy policies that reserve the right to share or sell data could be shared outside of the immediate campaign landscape to third parties, though selling them for commercial use is prohibited by law.

Americans seem to have no problem giving personal data to companies like Facebook, Google and Apple.

Companies like Google are so obsessed with privacy that visitors to their offices have to destroy their guest passes when they leave and are accompanied to the restrooms by a Google employee.

Political campaigns mostly fall on the other side of the spectrum. The laws that might force a Facebook or Google into a Congressional hearing on data breaches do not apply to political campaigns.

Professor Michael Zimmer of the University of Wisconsin, who specializes in Internet ethics and privacy issues, told The Guardian: “It’s one thing for a marketer to try to predict if people like Coke or Pepsi, but it’s another thing for them to predict things that are much more central to our identity. What’s more personal than how I interact with the world in terms of social and cultural issues.”

2 comments about "Privacy Worries: Politicians Collect Our Data-Then Can Sell It".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Jeremy Grimm from Kochava, January 22, 2016 at 5:04 p.m.

    Philip, I appreciate your insight and reporting, however, you make some broad generalizations that merit correction or factual reference. For instance “Companies like Google are so obsessed with privacy that visitors to their offices have to destroy their guest passes when they leave and are accompanied to the restrooms by a Google employee.


    This and other statements in your story are quite simply not true.  

  2. Philip Rosenstein from Law360, January 22, 2016 at 5:28 p.m.

    I appreciate your comment, Jeremy. My reference from Google offices is first hand, and I'd be happy to find people who were with me to corroborate those facts. 

    As for other statements, I'd be glad to address them. 

Next story loading loading..