Judge Denies Nielsen Motion, Allows Antitrust Suit To Proceed
"The court finds that, at a minimum [erinMedia's] complaint contains enough facts that [Nielsen] can properly identify the two elements required to state a claim for monopolization," wrote United States District Court Judge Susan C. Bucklew, denying Nielsen's motion to dismiss erinMedia's antitrust complaints--although she did dismiss a separate complaint by ReacTV, a fledgling interactive cable network that is affiliated with erinMedia. Both are owned by Florida real estate billionaire Frank Maggio, who has made challenging Nielsen's monopoly over the TV ratings business his personal crusade.
That crusade appears to have some merit, at least enough to keep the suit alive. Maggio's complaint alleges that erinMedia has been unable to compete in the TV ratings business due to Nielsen's "anticompetitive conduct, which impedes innovation and harms consumers." Assuming that erinMedia can prove those allegations, Bucklew wrote that it is "of the type that the antitrust laws were intended to prevent and the type of injury that the alleged violation would be likely to cause."
The judge's decision also appears to give validity to erinMedia's claim that it is a viable potential competitor for Nielsen, disagreeing with Nielsen's argument that erinMedia only plans to collect data from a "fraction of the national market." The judge noted that erinMedia plans to collect data from cable systems representing about 60 percent of the U.S. TV population, while Nielsen's "national" sample collects data from only about 8,000 households.
Nielsen executives were not available for comment at press time, but they previously had said they believed erinMedia's suit was "without merit" and would be dismissed by the court.
Recent MediaDailyNews Articles
-
Study Raises Doubts About Future of Social, Digital Shops May 21, 1:48 p.m.
Companies talk a lot about fully integrated marketing strategies. One result may be the demise of ... -
Out-Of-Home Trading Platform Integrates With Mediaocean, Posterscope Backs Move May 21, 8:07 a.m.
While it’s not quite the out-of-home equivalent of the online industry’s real-time trading systems, outdoor media ... -
Networks Top Goal: Ad Dollars Trump Studio-Produced Shows May 21, 8:06 a.m.
With Netflix and Amazon writing hefty checks, it bears watching whether networks will increasingly pick up ... -
Budweiser Bows New Campaign, Topped With Responsible-Drinking Blimp May 20, 5:26 p.m.
Summer is a time of concerts and festivals and beach-going, all of which carry the attendant ... -
Clear Channel Outdoor Unveils Consumer Networks May 20, 5:23 p.m.
Clear Channel Outdoor is creating a new way for advertisers to buy out-of-home ad inventory with ... -
Digital TV Video Biz Is Booming May 20, 4:10 p.m.
As traditional TV platforms project small gains in their $70 billion business, new digital TV video ... -
Initiative Wins Amazon's Global Media Account May 20, 3:09 p.m.
Interpublic Group’s Initiative has won global media duties for e-Commerce giant Amazon.com after a review.The company’s ... -
Media Storm Inks Ad Buying Deal With Videology May 20, 1:55 p.m.
Media Storm, which specializes in representing entertainment entities, such as FX and Food Network, has signed ... -
Mars Contract Suit Against Y&R Continues May 20, 11:56 a.m.
A New York judge has denied a request by WPP’s Y&R to toss out a breach ... -
Sony Debuts Marketing Campaign For 4K TV Sets May 20, 11:50 a.m.
While U.S. TV programming networks are not close to transitioning to the new 4K TV technology, ...
Be the first to comment on "Judge Denies Nielsen Motion, Allows Antitrust Suit To Proceed"
Leave a Comment