In the midst of sweeps season, the Brand Keys Customer Loyalty Index surveyed four TV morning news shows (on ABC, CBS, CNN and NBC) for audience attitudes. Four drivers - Good Hosts, Entertaining Features and Interviews, Trustworthy News Reporting, and Credible & Expert Guests - were the attributes identified that get viewers to turn to one channel over the others.
Here's how they fared:
Good Hosts. Apparently Katie Couric really earns all that loot. NBC wins by a knockout in this prime dimension, even beating the Ideal News Show. CNN & ABC tie for 2nd place charm. But what does it tell us about audience sophistication that the presenters rather than the information presented are the key elements in choosing a news service?
Entertaining Features & Interviews. Although none of the four networks surpassed the Ideal, once again NBC leads the pack, closely followed by ABC and CNN, and not so closely by CBS. It's interesting to note that "entertaining features" should be more important to news viewers than trustworthy news reporting although it's further confirmation of the melding of news and entertainment in the viewers consideration set.
Trustworthy News Reporting. Here CNN not only whacks the competition, but also the Ideal. This pioneering news service is widely considered within government circles to represent what Americans know about unfolding world events and 'breaking news.' Perhaps CNN is trusted because their on-the-spot 24/7 international coverage has produced scoops such as “Desert Storm Live From Baghdad." Although there is a "live drama" entertainment aspect to all reportage, and all good professional reporters know how to deliver it, CNN is perceived as doing it a little better than the three big networks.
Credible & Expert Guests. All of the shows beat the Ideal, probably because most people, knowing they are not experts themselves, take TV's word that the guests are competent. It seems to confirm the viewers' preference for showmanship and personality over content. We are already accustomed to "happy face" local morning news shows, starring cheery coffee-sipping yuksters who represent the same ethnic balance as their audience's demographic. But are we now witnessing the dumbing down of all news, even at the national and international level?
Robert Passikof, Ph.D is President of BandKeys, a loyalty research and consulting firm.