Undertone Networks Proves Privacy Stance, Joins NAI
Undertone Networks CEO Mike Cassidy said the move was partly driven by questions from online media buyers, who wanted to know whether the company belonged to the group. "Over the past six months, we've had two or three companies ask us about it," Cassidy said. While that number is low, it marks a significant change from prior years, when no marketers seemed to have the group on their radar, he said.
Undertone serves ads for around 350 premium media sites, and about 25 to 35% of its ads are targeted based on users' presumed interests as gleaned from their Web-surfing histories. Undertone's platform is cookie-based, meaning that users are recognized by cookies placed on their computers, but the company doesn't collect names, addresses or other personally identifiable information.
The 8-year-old Network Advertising Initiative was formed in response to concerns that a merger between DoubleClick--then mainly an ad network--and catalog database company Abacus posed a threat to people's privacy. The organization, which includes companies like Revenue Science, Yahoo and AOL's Advertising.com and Tacoda, requires companies that engage in behavioral targeting to tell consumers about the practice and allow them to opt-out.
But some privacy advocates say the association doesn't go far enough to protect privacy. Jeff Chester, executive director of the Center for Digital Democracy, holds that companies shouldn't deploy behavioral targeting techniques unless consumers have expressly consented. "Consent has to be opt-in," he said. "The NAI (Network Advertising Initiative) is absolutely flat wrong."
The group is currently revising its principles, but the new proposals still largely call for an opt-out regime.