Commentary

Image Is Everything

According to a recent Gallup Poll, Americans view four industries more positively now than they did in August 2001: the Internet industry, electric and gas utilities, and the computer and movie industries. The current 72% positive rating for the computer industry is the highest such rating of any industry since Gallup began tracking business sectors in 2001.

Americans' views of a number of sectors have worsened dramatically between 2001 and 2011, The images of the federal government and the real estate industry have dropped the most over the past decade. The percentage of Americans rating the government positively has declined 24 points since 2003, and the real estate industry's positive ratings have fallen 23 points since 2001. Other sectors with double-digit drops include the banking sector, education, accounting, and healthcare.

Americans view the computer industry the most positively and the federal government the least positively when asked to rate 25 business and industry sectors. All five of the top-rated sectors this year are related to either computers or food

The sectors Americans view most negatively have all had well-publicized problems in recent years. 17% of Americans have a positive view of the federal government, the lowest of any sector tested this year, while 63% have a negative image. Only one sector, oil and gas, has a higher negative percentage, 64%. Other poorly ranked sectors include real estate, healthcare, banking, and the legal field.

Overall View of Selected Business Sectors (% of U.S. Consumers)

Industry

% Positive

% Neutral

% Negative

Change in Positive Since 2001

Computer

72

16

10

5

Restaurant

61

25

12

-1

Internet

56

26

16

12

Farming & Agriculture

57

22

19

-2

Grocery

52

24

24

-5

Retail

44

33

22

-3

Travel

42

35

21

-8

Accounting

36

42

19

-11

Publishing

38

38

22

-9

Automobile

42

25

32

-3

Telephone

39

30

31

0

Movie

38

23

37

5

Sports

37

25

36

-1

Television & Radio

39

21

40

-3

Electric & Gas utilities

38

20

40

7

Advertising & PR

32

29

37

-6

Pharmaceutical

36

20

43

-3

Airline

29

30

39

-8

Education

35

18

47

-15

Legal

29

24

45

0

Banking

30

21

47

-17

Healthcare

27

18

55

-10

Real estate

23

23

52

-23

Oil & Gas

20

15

64

-4

Federal government

17

20

63

-24

Source: Gallup, August 2011

Gallup has asked Americans each August since 2001 to indicate whether they have positive or negative views of a list of business and industry sectors. The results range from a +62 net positive rating for the computer industry to a -46 net positive rating for the federal government.

The positive and the negative ratings for the federal government this year are the worst since Gallup began measuring its image in 2003.

Ratings of the Federal Government (% of Consumers; 2003-2011)

Year

Very/Somewhat Positive

Very/Somewhat Negative

2003

41%

35%

2004

34

39

2005

33

45

2006

25

50

2007

21

57

2008

18

60

2009

29

54

2010

26

58

2011

17

63

Source: Gallup, August 2011

The report makes the following observations about the changes in its concluding remarks:

  • The deterioration in Americans' views of the federal government began in 2004, correlated with a downturn in President George W. Bush's job approval rating and rising concerns about the Iraq war and the economy. Views turned slightly more positive in 2009 during Barack Obama's first year as president, but dropped back down last year and again this year, reflecting rising concerns over the economy as well as the increase in government spending and power, says the report.
  • The continuing high ratings for the computer and Internet industries likely reflect the global success of such American companies as Google, Apple, and Facebook, the technology industry's apparent success even in this time of economic uncertainty, and the increasingly major role that technology plays in Americans' lives. It is less clear why food-related sectors such as the restaurant industry, farming and agriculture, and the grocery industry do so well in the eyes of Americans, but it could reflect the United States' relatively noncontroversial and efficient food supply system.
  • At the other end of the spectrum, poorly rated sectors have been associated with various well-publicized political or economic problems in recent years. Americans' frustration with politicians and Washington, exacerbated by the contentious debt ceiling negotiations, comes through in the federal government's all-time low image rating. The oil and gas industry has never done well in these image assessments, which is likely tied to swings in gas prices and the overall high price of gas.
  • The bad image of the real estate industry most likely reflects the housing crisis that has beset the country in recent years, and the poor image of the healthcare industry may reflect the rising cost of healthcare and uncertainly about access issues. Americans continue to view banks poorly, which clearly reflects lingering concerns from the 2008 financial crisis and subsequent failure of many banks around the country. Lawyers and the legal field have never had positive images.

For complete top line metrics, please access the PDF file here, or for more from the summary release, go here.

  

1 comment about "Image Is Everything".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Mark Walker from aka Media Mark, September 6, 2011 at 4:42 p.m.

    It is a travesty to see that folks like Rush Limbaugh have so vilified the field of education, that it has slipped about the same amount as the banking industry- that actually dragged out country to the brink of depression, took our bail-out TARP money, loaned it out at extravagant rates of return and continue to raise fees and rates every day!

    As long as teachers continue to be dissed, education WILL actually suffer, and these talking heads' wished will come true.

    Vouchers anyone? Bueller, Bueller?

    What a world... what a world...

Next story loading loading..