string of successes in 2013, analysts are already questioning whether Netflix can hold its own in 2014.
Citing more competition in the digital video sector, a new report from Morgan
Stanley doubts whether the content company can sustain domestic subscription estimates going forward.
“We expect competition in U.S. digital video streaming to grow tighter in
2014 as services like Amazon Prime Instant Video, HBO GO and Hulu Plus offer compelling alternatives to Netflix’s service and each could corner specific segments of the market,” lead
analyst Scott Devitt warns in the report. “This could challenge Netflix’s gross subscriber growth and lead to higher US marketing [and] content costs.”
No one is
suggesting that Netflix isn’t coming off a great year. In fact, recent estimates from Needham & Co. suggested that the company surpassed HBO in the all-important category of paid U.S.
Boasting 31 million domestic subscribers, Netflix’s third-quarter earnings report sent investors into a tizzy, in late October. Having witnessed such euphoria
before, however, CEO Reed Hastings said such wild reactions by Wall Street are best to ignore. At the end of an investment letter, the seasoned CEO stated: “We do our best to ignore the
volatility in our stock."
Hastings, it appears, was wise to urge restraint. Morgan Stanley on Tuesday downgraded Netflix shares to underweight from equal-weight and lowered its target
price from $333 per share to $310 per share.
One issue: to meet Morgan Stanley’s 2014 domestic subscription forecast of 39 million, it estimates that over 48 million out of 92
million residential broadband households would need to watch Netflix over the next 12 months.
Devitt and his team still view Netflix as the most broadly appealing streaming video
service in the U.S. market, but predict that rivals services are offering increasingly compelling alternatives.
As for the broader market, Devitt said in the report: “We believe
digital video distribution has become largely commoditized, and it may be easier for some Netflix competitors to gain their next 5 million users than it will be for Netflix … Amazon and HBO
likely have millions of paying users that do not yet use their digital video platforms.”
Added Devitt: “If these services continue to grow in scale, bidding for quality
content could become more competitive, and likely, more costly.”
Making matters worse for Netflix and other paid-services, many of the major broadcast and cable networks are
streaming TV episodes on their Web sites for free for some period of time after the episodes air. CBS, for one, recently reported that online streaming was up 40%.
As for whether
streaming video become saturated in 2014, Morgan Stanley assured that the number of American consumers able to stream high-quality video continues to rapidly increase.