Landlines And Television Sets Losing Importance

According to a new nationwide survey from the Pew Research Center's Social & Demographic Trends project, reported by Paul Taylor and Wendy Wang with Lee Rainie and Aaron Smith, only 42% of Americans say they consider the television set to be a necessity. Last year, this figure was 52%, and in 2006, it was 64%.

After occupying center stage in the American household for much of the 20th century, says the report, two of the grand old luminaries of consumer technology, the television set and the landline telephone, are suffering from a sharp decline in public perception that they are necessities of life.

The drop-off has been less severe for the landline telephone. 62% of Americans say it's a necessity of life, down from 68% last year, but 47% of the public now say that the cell phone is a necessity of life.

What Americans Need (% Rating as Necessity)

Item

% Saying Necessity

% Change 2009-2010

Car

86%

-2%

Landline phone

62

-6

Clothes dryer

59

-7

Home air conditioning

55

+1

Home computer

49

-1

Cell phone

47

-2

Microwave

45

-2

TV set

42

-10

High speed Internet

34

+3

Cable or satellite TV

23

0

Dishwasher

21

0

Flat screen TV

10

+2

Source: PewResearchCenter, August 2010

In the case of the landline phone, the verdict does not come just from the survey, but also from the marketplace. According to a Pew Research Center analysis of government data, just 74% of U.S. households now have a landline phone, down from a peak of 97% in 2001. During this same time period, use of cell phones has skyrocketed. Fully 82% of adults now use cell phones, up from 53% in 2000. There are now more cell phones in the U.S. than landline phones.

From 1996 through 2006 a rising share of Americans saw more items on the list as necessities rather than luxuries. Since 2006, says the report, as the housing bubble burst, and consumer spending throttled down, the trend has moved the opposite way. A rising share now sees more everyday items as luxuries than necessities.

The report concludes that the dichotomy posed by the question "luxury or necessity" may be a relic. A more appropriate question in 2010 may be whether consumers consider these venerable appliances to be "necessary" or "superfluous."

The economy isn't the only factor driving these numbers, says the report. For several items on the list, the television set and the landline phone for instance, innovations in technology also seem to be playing a role.

Even as fewer Americans say they consider the TV set to be a necessity of life, more Americans than ever are stocking up on them. In 2009, the average American home had more television sets than people, 2.86, according to a Nielsen report. In 2000, this figure was 2.43; in 1990, it was 2.0; and in 1975, it was 1.57.

The disconnect between attitudes and behaviors, opines the report, may be that the TV set hasn't had to deal with competition from new technology that can fully replace all of its functions. If a person wants real-time access to the wide spectrum of entertainment, sports and news programming available on television, there's still nothing (at least not yet) that can compete with the television set itself.

Another twist to the TV story, though, comes from the flat-screen television. According to the latest Pew Research survey, 10% of the public now says that a flat-screen television is a necessity of life, up from 5% who felt that way in 2006. And according to industry reports, American consumers have bought more than 100 million flat-screen television sets since 2005.

For some items dependency increases with age, especially with the very-21st-century attitudes of today's young adults. Fewer than half of 18- to 29-year-old survey respondents consider the landline phone a necessity of life, while fewer than three-in-ten say the same about the television set. 

Approximate % of Group That Considers Item as a Necessity

Age

Landline

TV Set

Cable Service

Flat Screen TV

18-29

46%

29%

11%

10%

30-49

62

58

21

8

50-54

64

50

27

10

65+

77

53

35

17

Source: PewResearchCenter, August 2010

For other items, dependency decreases with age:

·      The cell phone decreases in importance from 59% of the 18-29 group to 29% among the 65+ group

·      Importance of the home computer goes from 53% of the younger group to 35% of the over 65s

·      High speed internet is important to 33% of the younger group, increases to around 40 from 30-64, and falls off to 15% for the 65+ crowd.

The "balance of necessity" between cell phones and landline phones shifts with the age of the respondent. Among 18- to 29-year-olds, more respondents consider a cell phone a necessity than a landline phone. For those in middle age, more consider a landline phone to be a necessity. And for those ages 65 and older, those who say the landline is a necessity outnumber those who say the same about a cell phone by a ratio of more than two-to-one.

Landline Phone vs. Cell Phone (% in Each Age Group)

Age Group

Landline a Necessity

Cell Phone a Necessity

18-29

46%

59%

30-49

62

51

50-64

64

43

65+

77

29

Source: PewResearchCenter, August 2010

As a June 2010 Pew Research Center report and other recent surveys of consumer behavior have shown, the deep recession that began in December 2007 has led to a new frugality in Americans' spending and saving habits, and it appears to have scrambled Americans' judgments about whether many everyday appliances are necessities or luxuries, says the report.

But one pattern is consistent across items studied. Their necessity rating was at (or very near) its peak four years ago, and has since declined. This suggests that the psyche of the American consumer is in a much different place now than it had been in the heady days before the recession, concludes the report.

For additional information please visit Pew Research here.

Recommend (61)
1 comment about "Landlines And Television Sets Losing Importance".
  1. Roy Fuchs from MFN , September 2, 2010 at 11:48 a.m.

    Two points bear on the land line-cell phone issue.

    First, is it possible that there are more cell phones than land line phones because every cell phone has a unique number, while one land line serves a whole household?

    Second, those of us who are older have a long history of land line usage, our "home phone" has been a necessity and a part of our identity for years, even if we last moved before we could port our number to our new address, while our cell phone is, relatively, new. One part of this is that we have been conditioned to giving our home number to companies with whom we do business, while most of us keep our cell phone for more personal uses.

    The change your next survey should record is to find out how many have replaced their Bell company service with Vonage, Skype or a similar service. At the same time, find out who's eliminating their fax line.