Indeed, to
his surprise, Manish Chandra, the founder of Kaboodle, said, "We were in discussions with multiple media companies and not really that much with tech companies for some reason." Does that mean Chandra
doesn't have faith in his site's new owners? Hearst, after all, is a traditional print publishing company.
Media companies are forking over tens of millions to hundreds of millions of dollars for companies that would be more appropriate for a Google or Yahoo. The result: déjà vu and skepticism among Web critics and financial analysts. Blogger Alan Mutter says, a former newspaper editor and current partner in the VC Tapit Partners, says "[traditional media co.'s] don't understand how Web publishing works." A couple of cases-in-point: NBC Universal's way overpriced $600 million purchase of iVillage in 2006, or Conde Nast's bizarre buy of Digg competitor Reddit earlier in the year. Digg, incidentally, continues to trounce its competition.