Commentary

MLB: More Polish, Less Spit?

When you have a 14-year-old-daughter you quickly learn that her career choices tend to change faster than the postings on her Facebook wall or her brand preferences, which can be fanatical one day and "so over" the next. It wasn't so long ago that she was going to "study in Paris and become a chocolate maker." That was followed by working with "adoption agencies to place kids." During the just-ended baseball playoffs she announced she wanted to become a "manager" or "whoever makes the rules for the players."

This decision was driven partly by our neighbor across the street inviting her to the final game of the American League Championship at Yankee Stadium, but her interest reached zealot status during the World Series. Her mission is not to reorganize the batting lineups or pitching rotations, or even give signals to the base runners. It is -- as she said vehemently at each offense -- to "Get them to stop spitting on the field."

No amount of lore about the MLB legacy of tobacco chawin' came anywhere close to dissuading her from her position that it is "just disgusting." It did not help that virtually every time Fox came in tight on a player close up (no matter if at the plate, on the mound, on the bases, in the field or on the bench) they immediately dribbled a loogy.

"See! See? They did it again!" became a clarion call in our family room, overriding whatever the game situation on the Big Screen TV. Having been thus sensitized (like back when Lucy used to drive Charlie Brown crazy by making him "aware of his tongue") I couldn't help BUT notice that baseball players indeed spit all the time, throughout the entire game, and not just in stressful situations. Guys eight places down the reliever chart, who wouldn't pitch in the game unless it went 27 or more innings, still sat in the bullpen spitting away. All of this really concerned my daughter, since most fields are now artificial turf and she likened it to "spitting on the carpet at your office." A cogent observation, to be sure.

Now, I played football, basketball and baseball growing up, and through a series of not altogether happy circumstances, found myself on national TV playing in the Gator Bowl, a situation one might consider to be stressful for a 21-year-old. Did I spit on the field? No. Did I ever spit on a playing field? Absolutely. Did I spit every 10 or 15 seconds like the big leaguers do? Never. If I was in a World Series game would I spit all the time? Nope (perhaps pee down my leg once or twice, but not spit).

I am certain there is some perfectly logical physiological reason why baseball players have the urge to spit throughout the game -- but fair warning, if my daughter ever becomes your manager, there could be some serious fines handed out. Congrats, Yankees. Spit and all.

3 comments about "MLB: More Polish, Less Spit?".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Charles Cuttone from Sports Vue Interactive, November 6, 2009 at 11:04 a.m.

    One point of fact in this story that is incorrect. Most Major League baseball fields are not artificial turf. In fact, there are only a handful left, in domed stadiums and one of those, in Minnesota will be gone next year when the club moves to a baseball only facility. That would leae just Tampa and Toronto with artificial turf.

  2. Jan Zlotnick from the zlotnick group, November 6, 2009 at 12:44 p.m.

    Your daughter's observation is correct: players spit and blow stuff out of their nose. Imagine if hockey or football or soccer or Kentucky Derby (!!!) featured the kind of constant upclose-and-(too)-personal shots we get in baseball? How 'bout if the U.S. Congress did their work outside, we'd be in for some real treats on C-Span. I kinda blame the broadcasting/camera director for some of this: when he/she directs a move to a particular camera zooming in on a particular face, if you don't know the human-nature and personality cues of impending saliva removal, well, you should. My favorites during the playoffs/world series were of A-Rod habitually tossing his gum on the field...or one shot of him doing the one-nostril blow out. These guys can't, or have decided not to, "help themselves" -- at some point, they have to just be themselves, whatever that is, to get them through an intensively high-pressure, ridiculously scrutinized (and yes, highly paid) job. If we watched reality "office" shows, can you imagine what we'd be seeing coming out of the noses, ears, mouths, and who knows where else, from people at their desks, at the water fountains, in the cafeterias, in the elevators? From a marketing/pr/branding POV, i do see the value of the company or at least their agent giving them a heads up, showing them film of how their behavior might have a impact on their brand's public/consumers. But then, it's up to them...if they need to spit to stay sane in that insanely scrutinized job, I'm giving them slack...
    - Jan Zlotnick http://www.thezlotnickgroup.com

  3. Paula Lynn from Who Else Unlimited, November 6, 2009 at 1:03 p.m.

    A tender hanky may not be possible on a ball field, but Stop chewin' that cancer tabaccy, and you'll stop spittin' so much.

Next story loading loading..