Horizon's Adgate: Hit Shows Hit By Poor Ratings

Brad Adgate

While the TV business continues to undergo radical digital platform changes, this particular television season has proven similar to the recent past: Single-digit percentage ratings losses and a slightly higher median age for many shows.

All networks were found to take some hits for the first two-and-a-half months of the season, according to a new report from Brad Adgate, senior vice president and corporate media director for media agency Horizon Media.

For example, NBC's "Heroes" lost 35.3% of its overall viewership to 5.6 million (and 40.5% among 18-49 viewers); Fox's "Fringe' caved 33.4% to 5.7 million viewers (and 43.2% in 18-49); CBS' "CSI' dropped 23.2% to 15 million (and 33.3% in 18-49); CBS' "Cold Case" withdrew 22.5% to 9 million (and 32.1% in 18-49); and NBC's "30 Rock" lost 21.4% to 6.2 million (and 21.1% in 18-49).

advertisement

advertisement

Other high-rated shows were down: ABC's "Grey's Anatomy" lost 9.7% among 18-49 viewers to a 5.6 average rating this year. CBS' "CSI: NY" slipped 13.9% to a 3.1 rating in 18-49 viewers. ABC's "Desperate Housewives" has dropped to a 4.7 rating, down 21.7%. NBC's "Law and Order: SVU" is now off 27.8% to a 2.6 rating.

Better results this year so far have been attained by CBS' "The Big Bang Theory" -- 38.1% higher to 12.9 million viewers, and up to an average 4.8 rating among 18-49 viewers, from a 3.6 in 2008. ABC's "Private Practice," on a new night, climbed 27% to 9.8 million viewers reaching a 3.7 rating in 18-49 viewers from a 2.8 the year before.

NBC's "The Biggest Loser" grabbed 21.2% more viewers to 9.1 million, and rose to a 3.6 rating among 18-49 viewers from a 3.1 number. NBC's "Sunday Night Football" grew 18.7% to 18.4 million viewers and climbed to a 7.2 average rating among 18-49 viewers, from a 6.0 the year before.

CBS' "NCIS" continued its resurgence from a year ago, rising 14.9% to 20.3 million viewers and improving to a 4.4 rating among 18-49 viewers from a 3.6 a year earlier.

Fox's "House," now on Monday nights, has been one major reason for that network's improvement during the period. The drama grew 13.4% among all viewers to 14 million, and rose to a 5.5 rating among 18-49 viewers.

Three reality shows had increases among overall viewership: NBC's "The Biggest Loser" (21.2%), CBS' "Amazing Race" (5.6%) and "Survivor" (6.2%). Moving in the other direction were ABC's "Dancing with the Stars" (down 8.5%) and CW's "America's Next Top Model" (down 18.6%).

CW is done with its new "Vampire Diaries," but many of its returning shows have suffered in overall viewership: "Smallville" dropped 39.8%; "Gossip Girl" was off 30.9%; "90210" slipped 28.3%; "One Tree Hill" was 25.3% lower; and "Supernatural" sank 22.4%.

Adgate says that shows with a notable increase in median age from a year ago include ABC's "Supernanny", 52.9 years old (+5.9); NBC's "Law & Order" (new night), 59.1 years old (+5.2); NBC's "Law & Order: SVU" (new night), 52.1 years old (+4.9); Fox' "Fringe" (new night), 47.5 years old (+4.8), and CW's "One Tree Hill", 29.3 years (+3.8).

3 comments about "Horizon's Adgate: Hit Shows Hit By Poor Ratings".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Rob Frydlewicz from DentsuAegis, December 2, 2009 at 11:04 a.m.

    What type of ratings are these, i.e., Live, Live +Same Day or C3? Also, I'm curious which shows, if any, got younger.

    www.HistoryAsYouExperiencedIt.com

  2. Robin Vogel from From the Loins Greetings, December 2, 2009 at 4:14 p.m.

    Are you figuring in the DVR taping with these numbers? Because it seems to me that without adding in those additional viewers, your ratings are going to be seriously skewed in the wrong direction.

    On Thursday night, for example, my favorite show is SUPERNATURAL. I watch AND DVR that show because I like to watch each episode several times until the DVD for the season comes out. I also DVR GREY'S ANATOMY, CSI, and FRINGE. (I own two DVR boxes because we're big TV watchers in my family). In addition to that, I TAPE on my VCR THE OFFICE and 30 ROCK for my son. So how do you account for all that?

    My point is, all your figures only account for live TV viewing, which, these days, does not show the TRUE watching figures of a TV show. If you believe that only live TV viewers watch commercials, guess again. I read magazines and newspapers during the ads, which, during SUPERNATURAL, are incredibly long (as much as 4-5 minutes) and boring.

    I really am curious as to how you gathered your data and just how accurate it is. I suspect it's as outdated as the current Nielsen figures themselves are, and just as in need of a major overhaul.

    Robin Vogel

  3. Mike Einstein from the Brothers Einstein, December 3, 2009 at 9:35 a.m.

    No mystery here. You want better numbers? Try producing something worth watching.

Next story loading loading..