Commentary

Accidentally Messing Up Your Brand

We often talk about how nimble digital is, how swiftly it can be gauged and optimized. This implies in some ways that digital is easy. But we know better -- we know the complexities and how they in fact mount as we advance the medium. It occurred to me recently that given the way we regard and talk about digital, some things are truly easier said than done. And that's a bit of a trap.

Last week, eMarketer shared some stats on the distortion of company messages within the blogosphere. The numbers are pretty astounding, with a global average of 69% of blog postings not reflecting the company's or brand's intention.

This piece resonated with me, as so many of us are asked by our clients to advise them on their social media  execution. The topic comes up in every single integrated digital engagement. We tend to point to a "playbook" that may or may not exist -- or that we might help create -- or to the wisdom of hiring specialists. Such a playbook would guide a team as a sort of style guide and punch list to social media execution.

While distortion is also a factor in traditional media, it's apparently far greater within digital. Many factors come to mind, but somewhat fixated on this chart and the numbers over the weekend, I wanted to share a few, based on my own observation and frequent conversations with client services folk.

1.    A company or brand will try to migrate PR efforts to a more expansive, blogosphere-inclusive, social media approach without a real game plan, without differentiating traditional approaches, and without addressing potential staffing inadequacies.

advertisement

advertisement

2.    Feeling the itch if not pressure to go wider into the consumer marketplace, more often than not a company just goes flat-out in the social realm. They move too quickly, before basic style can be agreed upon or before proper attention can be given to voice.

3.    A company honestly believes social efforts can be handled by interns. While it's true that young, exuberant, digitally savvy interns can provide essential juice, the background business acumen, marketing savvy, and attendance to consumer insights of more experienced staff are key to really marshaling the effort.

4.    A brand in peril believes that social media's sole purpose is as a customer complaint conduit. Yes, social can be used for brilliant customer service handling, but such a singular approach is not stretching the medium enough.

5.    As highlighted in the eMarketer piece, a brand does not put its owned media to work, and doesn't take care to create original content that could be distributed or optimized above and beyond standard press fodder. This might take the form of a company blog and blog-rolling, distributed content snack, and buzz-building sequences of releasing content.

Our own digital enthusiasm may lead us to oversimplify our view of certain methods in the mix. And, yes, social media seems to take the lead on easier said than done when it comes to technique. So, there's wisdom to creating a playbook, establishing a certain manner and map within the team that is handling your social strategy -- or at least slowing down to make sure all efforts are tuned. After all, the idea of idly inflicting harm, at the rate at which we apparently are, seems pretty ridiculous.

6 comments about "Accidentally Messing Up Your Brand ".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Scott Brinker from ion interactive, inc., October 11, 2010 at 10:25 a.m.

    Brilliant article -- a message that needs to be heard.

  2. Paula Lynn from Who Else Unlimited, October 11, 2010 at 10:47 a.m.

    How about safe guards? Are there any? I cannot wrap my head around that your business like whether you like red or not is everybody's and every advertiser's business. If you want to know more about me and are my friend, you will call me or even email me directly. Anything about you can be used against you if necessary. Bet you all thought 1984 was a futuristic story.

  3. Greg Alvarez from iMeil, October 11, 2010 at 12:17 p.m.

    6. - A company that in a childish manner believes their consultants are right when they suggest to go social "starting a page or space on a social network". Social marketing is not a page on Facebook, nor one in Twitter, and even its not a space on Linked-In. Social media even does not need "young people wasting tons of time on social networking sites".

  4. Ralph Sherman from Madison2Main, October 11, 2010 at 12:47 p.m.

    Many digital observers have made these points but few in such a simple, direct and eloquent way. Every CMO and Ad Director should read this, and a few agency leads, too.
    One of the great benefits of digital is the ability to experiment, measure and integrate--that will lead to less distortion and more brand harmony.

  5. Mark Burrell from Tongal, October 11, 2010 at 6:37 p.m.

    this is a great article!

  6. Joe Bencharsky from iNet Entertainment, October 18, 2010 at 12:22 a.m.

    Traditional Brand managers need to extend their own perceptions of branding to survive in an interactive rather than dictatorial brand environment. This means developing a brand lexicon and talented writers to make sure branding is consistent across social media and in new digital forms. It's a new world and the old brand mindsets will not survive.

Next story loading loading..