Armed with a yellow highlighter, and determined to distill the important insights in this important, almost 400-page book, I dove into the recently published “American Girls: Social Media and
the Secret Lives Of Teenagers” by Nancy Jo Sales.
But I couldn't even get through the introduction without coloring almost all of the text.
As a wired human, I was aware of
problems with kids and sexting and cyberbullying, etc. But I really wasn’t prepared for how widespread these troubling behaviors are.
First, let’s not be alarmist. Obviously, with
their still-developing limbic systems, “teenagers” have been acting out sexually since before there was even such a word in the lexicon to connote them as non-grownups. Everyone from
Shakespeare to Springsteen has turned such outlaw coupling among “youtes” into an art form.
But truly, the growth of online porn -- and teenagers’ access to the Internet --
have radically changed the behaviors of teenaged boys and girls.
advertisement
advertisement
Compound that with the introduction of smartphones, which hit the market in 2007. By now, smartphone ownership among teenagers
is so widespread that they sometimes see these often violent and misogynistic porn-based images on their hand-held screens before they have even have had a chance to hold hands or share a first
kiss.
“We are in uncharted territory,” with the Internet “changing so much about the way we act both romantically and sexually, [that it’s] unprecedented from a
revolutionary standpoint,” says Justin Garcia, a research scientist at Indiana University’s Kinsey Institute for Research in Sex, Gender, and Reproduction, whom Sales quotes in the
book.
“Social media is destroying our lives,” one of the girls tells Sales.
“So why don’t you go off?” the author asked.
“Because then
we would have NO life,” the kid said.
That, in a nutshell, is what’s going on.
Sales, a writer for Vanity Fair and author of “The Bling
Ring,” a book about a gang of affluent, celebrity-oriented teen thieves, spent two-and-a-half years researching this book, visiting 10 states and talking to all kinds of girls, ages
13-19, about their lives on and off social media. (Full disclosure: we worked together many years ago at New York magazine.)
After interviewing these kids, Sales started following the
apps and messaging services they favored, including three I hadn’t heard of: Yik Yak, the “anonymous Twitter,” Kik, and Yeti, a sort of X-rated Snapchat.
The biggest takeaway
in an age when girls learn to measure their worth in the number of "likes" they receive on Instagram posts is that sexuality has become a new form of Internet currency, used both to attract boys and
impress and compete with girlfriends.
“Things once considered sexist have been reinterpreted by and for girls as 'empowering': beauty pageants, stripping, even porn,” Sales
says.
The book is divided into seven chapters, each devoted to one year in the life of teen girldom from ages 13-19.
Chapter one opens in the leafy, upper-middle-class suburb of
Montclair, N.J., with the message “SEND NOODZ.”
That was a text 13-year-old Sophia received via direct-message on Instagram from a boy she barely knew. She didn’t know how to
respond. (Her emotions were all over the place, including “Whoa, he finds me attractive?”) He later texted her, “I really need this cause I have to win a bet. I won’t
show anyone.”
But Sophia didn’t send the "NOODZ." And Sales followed the trail to find the boy himself, who admitted that he was trading these pictures for liquor, sending
them to older kids who curated pages of nude-girl selfies. (Yes, that’s another thing.)
The book shows that as the girls age, they start internalizing some of these “ho”
messages as just fun, and having porn-influenced sex, which is often rough. (One thing missing from the book: an acknowledgement of the work of advertising consultant Cindy Gallop, who launched the
Web site “Make Love, Not Porn” devoted to this very problem, during a TED Talk in 2009.)
Sales talks about the rise of rape culture on social media: “Google “rape-based
sex” and see how many hits you get,” Sales says. Top Snapchat features favor topics like “Throwing up, being drunk, getting hung over, being re-drunk.”
It’s not all horrific news, however. Sales says that there's a lot of feminist activism on social media
that’s empowering girls. In one of the later chapters on older teens, a girl discusses the Black Lives Matter movement and how this kind of social media activism made a big positive change in
her life.
In an interview, Sales told me that she is getting questions from parents of teenagers who describe themselves as “overwhelmed” about social media and say they have no
awareness or tools to deal with it, having grown up in a Facebook-less age.
“I’m not a parenting expert,” Sales said, “But we have to help [teenagers] and guide them.
It’s OK sometimes to say no. Give them boundaries! If you think it’s inappropriate, you’re the parent. What’s the problem?"
And as awkward and embarrassing as it may
be, perhaps both parents and kids should read the book and discuss it.
“The real world we inhabit together is the one that matters,” is how Sales ends the book. “We need to
find a way of navigating ourselves and our children back there, to the world of true and lasting connection.”
And short of banishing them to the Himalayas or an Israeli kibbutz, maybe
parents can start a “no-phone-Fridays”-for-teenagers movement. It can’t hurt.