I spent most of my professional life inside the high-tech bubble. Having now survived the better part of a decade outside said bubble, I have achieved enough distance to be able to appreciate the lampooning skills of Dan Lyon.
If that name doesn’t sound familiar, you still may have seen his work. He was the real person behind the Fake Steve Jobs blog. He was also the senior technology editor for Forbes and Newsweek prior to being cut loose in the print media implosion. He later joined the writing staff of Mike Judge’s brilliant HBO series "Silicon Valley."
Somewhere in that career arc, Lyons briefly worked at a high-tech start up. From that experience, he wrote "Disrupted: My Misadventure in the Start-Up Bubble.” It gives new meaning to the phrase “painfully funny.”
After being cast adrift by Forbes, Lyons decided to change his perspective on the bubble from “outside looking in” to “inside looking out.” He wanted to jump on the bubble band wagon, grab a fistful of options and cash in. And so he joined HubSpot as a content producer for its corporate blog. The story unfolds from there.
One particularly sharp and insightful chapter of the book recalls Steve Job’s “Bozo Explosion”: “Apple CEO Steve Jobs used to talk about a phenomenon called a ‘bozo explosion,’ by which a company’s mediocre early hires rise up through the ranks and end up running departments. The bozos now must hire other people, and of course they prefer to hire bozos. As Guy Kawasaki, who worked with Jobs at Apple, puts it: ‘B players hire C players, so they can feel superior to them, and C players hire D players.’ “
The Bozo Explosion is somewhat unique to tech start-ups, mainly because of some aspects of the culture I talked about in a previous column. But I ran into my own version back in my consulting career. And I ran into it in all kinds of companies. I used to call it the Mediocrity Sandwich.
The Mediocrity Sandwich lives in middle management. I found the people at the C Level of the company usually pretty smart and competent (that said, I did run across some notable exceptions in my time). I also found the people on the customer-facing front lines of the company were also pretty smart and -- more importantly -- very aware of the company’s own issues.
But addressing those issues invariably caused a problem. You had senior executives who were certainly capable of fixing the problems, whatever they might be. And you had front-line employees who were painfully aware of what the problems were and motivated to implement solutions. But all the momentum of any real problem-solving initiative used to get sucked out somewhere in the middle of the corporate org chart. The problem was the Mediocrity Sandwich.
You see, I don’t think the Bozo Explosion is so much a pyramid -- skinny at the top, broad at the bottom -- as it is an inverted U-Shaped curve. I think “bozoism” tends to peak in the middle. You certainly have the progression from As to Bs to Cs as you move down from the top executive rungs. But then you have the inverse happening as you move from middle management to the front lines. The problem is the attrition of competence as you become absorbed into the organization. It’s the Bozo Explosion in reverse.
I usually found there was enough breathing room for competence to survive at the entry level in the organization. There were enough degrees of separation between the front line and the bozos in middle management. But as you started to climb the corporate ladder, you kept getting closer to the bozos. Your degree of job frustration began to climb as they had more influence over your day-to-day work.
Truly competent players bailed and moved on to a less bozo-infested environment. Those that remained either were born bozos or had “bozo”ness thrust upon them. Either way, as you climbed towards middle management, the bozo factor climbed in lockstep. The result? A bell curve of bozos centered in the middle between the C-Level and the front lines.
This creates a poisonous outlook for the long-term prospects of a company. Eventually, C-level executives will age out of their jobs. But who will replace them? The internal farm team is a bunch of bozos. You can recruit from outside, but then the incoming talent inherits a Mediocrity Sandwich. The company begins to rot from within.For companies to truly change, you have to root out the bozo rot, but this is easier said than done. If there's one single thing bozos are good at, it is bozo butt-covering.