Stump checked with the Wayback machine at Archive.org, and found that the site had been owned by spammers
for the previous two years. As such, it had incurred heavy penalties from the three major engines, and trying to get those penalties removed has proven to be a challenge.
While Stump has been able to get indexed by Yahoo (after getting in touch with a live representative), he's had little luck with the reentry process for Google and MSN. While he can try to drive additional traffic via PPC, the Onlyhammocks.com site is stuck in poorly indexed limbo while the two engines complete their review process.