Call Me Maybe? The Key To Effective Advertising

by Jim Madsen , December 5, 2012

Hey, I just met you,

And this is crazy,

But here’s my number,

So call me, maybe?

Call Me Maybe was the song of Summer 2012. But Carly Rae Jepsen’s catchy little earworm contained a truth that everyone should heed. If you want someone to call you, they’ll need your number.

Duh.

So how does a no-brainer like this get lost in the world of advertising?

Because agencies and advertisers don’t realize their brand-building commercials have morphed into direct-response ones. Somehow, a Web site address or 800 number snuck in, and this changes everything. Oh, they still retain all the branding elements -- the ads position products and services strategically and with impact. They possess great production values and don’t look like traditional two-minute direct-response spots.

But these commercials have become all flirtation, with no follow-through. They want viewers to respond, but they don’t provide sufficient motivation or information for them to do so.

No matter how sexy a spot looks, how cleverly it’s written, how accurately it’s targeted, or even how much social media it uses, it won’t make the register ring repeatedly without doing what Carly does: making it easy to call or click. These days, advertisers want their ads to be accountable -- even their brand-building commercials -- and so customers need a phone number, a link, a point of sale. But once a commercial tries to evoke a response with an 800 number or URL or even a retailer location, it has crossed the line from general to direct-response advertising.

Direct-response leverages brand, strategy, creative and media. But it doesn’t leave its audience hanging. It takes their hand and invites them to the next step forward, toward making an actual purchase.

Branding is great -- and if branding is the sole purpose of the ad, then forget about Carly’s message. But if any type of response is requested, then think about that message long and hard.

The next time you see a commercial, ask yourself two questions:

Do I know exactly where or how I can buy this product? Do I care enough to call or click?

Don’t get me wrong. Having a great product with smart advertising will definitely get you noticed. But until you’re as well-known as Apple, Pepsi, or Carly Rae Jepsen, the register won’t ring as much as it should until you follow through with those magic words: …here’s my number, so call me, maybe?

commentary

5 comments about "Call Me Maybe? The Key To Effective Advertising".

Check to receive email when comments are posted.

Mike Anderson from CSS, December 5, 2012 at 9:27 a.m.
Jim, this is a great reminder of the fundamentals. In a world that simply demands greater accountability for its advertising dollar, and in an age when consumers want everything to be convenient... the response path needs to be very clear and convenient. That's doesn't need to mean, "Call before midnight tonight." It can be as simple as delivering an Inbound Marketing offer, where consumers can hit a landing page and download more information, or other such offer. Ads are too often focused on what we want people to think or feel, and not focused enough on what we want them to DO.
Reply

Paula Lynn from Who Else Unlimited, December 5, 2012 at 9:50 a.m.

Reminds me of the time I acquired a suburban bank account. The material came in without addresses or phone numbers so I called the agency to explain. They said it was deliberate because the client insisted that interested people would find them. The ad ran 4 times and then said it didn't work and didn't renew. Old story - same equation.

Jim Madsen from A. Eicoff & Company, December 5, 2012 at 6:27 p.m.

Thanks Mike. You're right, it can be so simple -- and effective.

Jim Madsen from A. Eicoff & Company, December 5, 2012 at 6:29 p.m.

Paula -- Some agencies will do cool things for effect, at the expense of being effective.

Paula Lynn from Who Else Unlimited, December 6, 2012 at 7:45 p.m.

Jim, I can agree with you with some, especially now.
That one was not. It was a part of the central PA mentality.