Commentary

Yahoo's Broken Promises: Shows Announced Last Spring Never Happened

Doesn’t the ad industry ever get weary of the BS they hear at the Upfronts and NewFronts every spring?

It’s true that most of the TV networks and Web sites make their announcements of new shows with all good intentions -- even Yahoo, most likely.

Still, amid the turmoil making headlines once again about Yahoo -- most notably, its ongoing struggle to make money and the allegations of profligate spending attributed to CEO Marissa Mayer -- it takes your breath away to think back to the company’s NewFront presentation last April and consider everything that has not come to pass in the months since.

It was one of the biggest such events of the whole Upfront/NewFront season, which stretched from late February to mid-May. Yahoo’s NewFront was held at Lincoln Center, in prestigious Avery Fisher Hall, on Monday evening, April 27. The line to get in stretched from the Hall’s doors, across the Lincoln Center plaza all the way to 62nd Street.

advertisement

advertisement

The presentation seemed to pack the Hall -- capacity 2,738 seats. A techno-DJ provided music designed to pump up the crowd and/or burst the eardrums. A press release issued that day said Yahoo announced “18 new series” at its “2015 Digital Content NewFront.” 

Maybe they announced 18, but I can only remember them announcing four, with two of them standing out as the shows Yahoo touted the most. Guess what: Neither show ever saw the light of day.

One was a music competition show called “Ultimate DJ” from producer Simon Cowell, which was the reason why a DJ had so prominent a spot in the Hall that evening. This show was supposed to do for club DJs what “American Idol” had done for pop music. Unfortunately for club DJs the world over, “Ultimate DJ” was abandoned a few months later.

The other “big show” Yahoo announced was called “The Pursuit,” a network-television-style sitcom that Yahoo boasted would be a modern-day “Friends.” “The Pursuit” (as in: “the pursuit of happiness”) was supposed to be about a group of 20-somethings living in New York in the present day. “Friends” need never worry about being overtaken by “The Pursuit.” This show -- so ballyhooed at the NewFront last April -- was abandoned also.

Three other shows were highlighted at the Yahoo NewFront too -- “I Am Naomi,” described as a talk show hosted by fashion model Naomi Campbell; “Riding Shotgun with Michelle Rodriguez,” a car series featuring Rodriguez, one of the stars of the “Fast and Furious” movies; and “Community,” the low-rated NBC sitcom that Yahoo picked up after NBC cancelled it.

The news that Yahoo had decided not to go ahead with “Ultimate DJ” and “The Pursuit” was widely reported last year. I searched for similar such stories about “I Am Naomi” and “Riding Shotgun,” but found none, which leads me to believe they may not have been abandoned. However, I couldn’t find them on Yahoo’s own Web site, so who knows?

As for “Community,” its sixth season ran on Yahoo from last March to June. It was a centerpiece of Yahoo’s on-demand streaming service, Yahoo Screen, which Yahoo shut down earlier this month. “Community” won’t be back for a seventh season.

At Yahoo’s NewFront last April, the company’s new shows were announced principally by Kathy Savitt, chief marketing offer and head of media. She left the company last September. She went to work for STX Entertainment.

What’s the point of this trip down NewFront Memory Lane? Just this: As Yahoo has no doubt discovered, getting TV shows from the idea stage to actually airing them is not easy. Making announcements and promises about new shows -- and spending lavishly on a glitzy presentation at Lincoln Center in New York -- are apparently much easier, even for a company whose inner workings are as chaotic as Yahoo’s. If Yahoo plans on having another such presentation this spring, here’s hoping it produces something more than just hot air.

3 comments about "Yahoo's Broken Promises: Shows Announced Last Spring Never Happened ".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Ari Rosenberg from Performance Pricing Holdings, LLC, January 11, 2016 at 1:03 p.m.

    Nice piece Adam.  In your experience, has a traditional television network ever abandoned this many shows preseneted at the upfront?  I suspect not because I sense this is an example of how many Internet based companies tend to act.  It's a "speed to market, let's figure it out later" mentality which ultimately as you point out, hurts the credibility to the company itself.  Even if these shows did launch, I suspect the metrics supporting their success come with so many questions...there is lots more to learn and get better at for the Yahoo's of the world.

  2. Jonathan Hutter from Northern Light Health, January 11, 2016 at 1:41 p.m.

    I still don't get how the "NewFronts" ever came to be. Of all the models the online world could pick to market its content, offerings and experience, it picked a model from a medium it claims is completely different, with no similar measures and engagements. If someone has more inside information than I do, I'm all ears (not the rabbit kind).

  3. Ed Papazian from Media Dynamics Inc, January 11, 2016 at 4:41 p.m.

    As I point out repeatedly in my new book, "TV Now and Then", developing and producing "quality" content is not an easy game and it takes experienced execs who understand how TV producers work--and their limitations----to run such operations. Did Yahoo employ such people or was all of the fuss mainly hype and hoopla? This is not the first time that a major digital entity tried such a gambit, nor will it be the last. However if this disaster---or series of disasters--- demonstrates anything, it shows the need for a long range strategic plan and qulaified execs with a long term mandate to create a winning program lineup. How many Yahoos have such capabilities? One can only wonder?

Next story loading loading..