Do You Ever Wonder Why Baby Boomers Are Not Loyal To Your Brand?

Companies, often encouraged by legal counsel, regularly resist expressing vulnerability, sometimes at great expense. A classic example took place in the early 1980. The Audi 5000 was reported to accelerate spontaneously from a stand-still without driver involvement. Audi responded with not even a token amount of compassion and vulnerability. It said simply that drivers were at fault. 

Audi sales in the U.S. plummeted from nearly 75,000 to barely 12,000 cars. Moreover, a little-known fact is that Audi was ultimately vindicated by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. It ruled that driver error did in fact cause the unintended acceleration. But because NHTSA’ ruling received little media attention – bad news gets more and bigger headlines – it took Audi more than 12 years to bring sales back to the original levels. 

Companies spend vast sums fortifying and defending themselves against legal challenges by customers while apparently not realizing that the roots of a claim might lie in a breach of the emotional contract between a company and customer. People don’t sue people or organizations for whom they feel affection – or as advertising guru Kevin Roberts would say, “that they love.”



Numerous studies have found that it costs more to get a new customer than to keep an existing customer. Baby Boomer customers are no exception. Moreover, their level of response to authenticity, honesty and the willingness of a company to be vulnerable is higher. In addition, research has shown that existing customers tend to spend more money with a company than new customers do. It makes a lot of sense to devote time to creating a book of evergreen Baby Boomer customers (the term "evergreen" can refer metaphorically to something that is continuously renewed) not only because they are likely prospects for new purchases and have the most disposable income of any demo. 

Boomers will also be your richest source of referrals. Companies spend lots of money doing customer satisfaction surveys. However, that’s wasted money for many companies because they don’t realize that people often report satisfaction with a product or a company but don’t have any deep sense of loyalty. 

You want your customers to be more than satisfied. You want them to be loyal. Satisfaction is often determined by left-brain analysis, such as coming up with an answer to this question: “On a scale of 1-10, how satisfied were you with “the product/service” you bought?” Customer satisfaction is mostly about what a Baby Boomer thinks about a company or brand. Loyalty is mostly about how they feel about a company or a brand. Satisfaction surveys tend to focus on the details of the transaction. Nevertheless, what brings Baby Boomers back repeatedly is the experience they have with a company. 

Toro, the giant lawn mower maker, learned that by delivering better on the emotional contract it could decrease personal injury lawsuits. Toro’s leadership once believed personal injury litigation was inevitable, given the nature of its products. However, in the mid-1990s company reps began personally contacting injured customers. They apologetically extended the company’s sympathy and suggested that if an immediate settlement could not be arranged, arbitration could be a better than going to court. 

The $1.5 billion company used non-threatening paralegals, experienced settlement counselors and mediators familiar with Toro's preference for early case resolution. Since adopting this emotionally sensitive approach in1994, we’ve uncovered no evidence that Toro has been in court for a single personal injury case. This is a truly amazing record for a company that builds dangerous equipment that falls into countless careless hands every weekend of the year. Toro estimated it saved more than estimated $100 million in litigation costs since it kicked off its non-aggressive approach to avoiding litigation in 1991.

Isn’t the idea of the emotional contract simple common sense? Think of how things are between you and those with whom you have close relationships. When they make you feel good, you cut them some slack when they mess up a little bit. However, if you’re already down on them, aren’t you likely to call them on every mistake? Baby Boomers become evergreen customers when you have delivered strongly on the emotional contract.

3 comments about "Do You Ever Wonder Why Baby Boomers Are Not Loyal To Your Brand?".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Liz Dahl from Liz Dahl Enterprises, March 7, 2016 at 11:12 a.m.

    I'm so delighted that you continue to value the Baby Boomer market, because we are loyal, have the money and want to be heard and seen. What I do not understand is why ad agencies and marketers still do not seem to comprehend or accept this. As founder of, I am trying to be the voice for this group, as far as travel goes, but I seem to meet resistance from marketers. What will it take for them to get the message?

  2. Michael Elling from IVP Capital, LLC, March 7, 2016 at 11:13 a.m.

    Having driven the rebadged Audi 100 many years after the original sudden acceleration issue I noticed that the steering wheel was maybe a millimeter (or a few) right of center.  I attributed this to Audi's leading-edge front-drive concept that might have required such a design.  

    Of course I'm not sure, but by 1991 I had probably driven 50+ different vehicles (mine, friends, rentals) and was pretty astute about ergonomic differences.  I noticed it right away in the show-room floor even before I bought the car (at a huge discount off of sticker).

    I reasoned that this 1-3mm difference might have confused some people who looking for the edge of the brake pedal using the steering column as "dead-center" missed and hit the gas.  This could also have happened with lazier or less attentive drivers who only shifted their feet on their heels instead of lifting and stepping.  After that it would be pretty clear that a disoriented person couldn't easily recover from the mistake in time.

    It would be great to know if anyone suggested this as a potential causal factor.

  3. James Smith from J. R. Smith Group, March 7, 2016 at 11:43 a.m.

    Jim, you made some excellent points on the customer satisfaction issues.  Some service companies figured it out long ago, that customer satisfaction is a multivariate, not univariate concept and of course purchase patterns (loyalty) and transaction satisfaction are key parts...they are not the only parts. It's the entire CRM effort.  Rather than scale such high data walls, some firms seem to wait until the outcry hits a critical mass, then take action. Which kinda makes about as much sense as ignoring maintaining wellness when it comes to patient health.

    I'm not sure marketers in general ignore Boomers but a strong case could be made that many aren't looking at the buying power numbers. Other marketers, still enraputured with 18-49 might view the entire Boomer population as "evergreens."  And you only loose an evergreen if it dies or you cut it down.

Next story loading loading..