Google is urging a judge to dismiss a lawsuit alleging that the company's voice-activated Assistant illegally records people's conversations without their consent, and discloses snippets of conversations to outside contractors.
The company's papers come in response to a class-action lawsuit brought earlier this year by five consumers -- Asif Kumandan, Melissa Spurr and her child, identified only as “B.S.,” Loudes Galvan and Eleeana Galvan.
They brought suit several weeks after the Dutch radio broadcaster VRT reported that Google Home smart speakers and Google Assistant were transmitting consumers' conversations to Google, even when people hadn't first given the “Hey, Google” or “OK, Google” commands. (Those hotwords signal an intention to interact with the devices.)
VRT also reported on its website that Google sometimes sends portions of users' conversations to outside contractors who analyze language patterns. VRT said it had listened to more than 1,000 excerpts of conversations -- including 153 where participants hadn't said a hotword. An outside contractor shared the voice snippets with VRT, in apparent violation of Google's policies.
Google counters that even if its Assistant records conversations after mistakenly interpreting words or background noise as a command, the unintentional error doesn't violate any privacy laws or promises to consumers.
“An inadvertent error in hotword detection does not amount to a violation of federal or state privacy laws or breach any promise made to consumers,” Google writes.
“These provisions squarely permit the alleged disclosure of audio data to subcontractors for processing and analysis to improve the functionality of the Assistant,” Google writes.