The Senate Tuesday voted 49-46 along party lines to confirm
controversial telecom lawyer Nathan Simington to the Federal Communications Commission.
The move means President-elect Joe Biden will begin his term with two Democratic commissioners and two
Republican ones -- which could hinder his broadband policy agenda, including the restoration of net neutrality rules.
Biden will be able to nominate someone to fill the fifth slot at the
agency, but it's not clear whether a Republican-led Senate will approve -- or even consider -- that nominee.
President Trump nominated Simington after abruptly withdrawing the re-nomination of
FCC Commissioner Michael O'Rielly, who had expressed skepticism toward Trump's request to gut Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act-- the 24-year-old media law that undergirds the modern
web.
Section 230 protects web publishers from liability when users' posts are defamatory or otherwise unlawful. It also immunizes companies from lawsuits for decisions about content moderation
decisions. The First Amendment also shields companies from decisions about content moderation, but Section 230 can offer companies an easier path to victory when they're sued over moderation
decisions.
Simington, a senior adviser at the Commerce Department's National Telecommunications and Information Administration, helped write the agency's petition to the FCC for rules to
weaken Section 230. He also reportedly attempted to influence Fox News' coverage of controversies surrounding Section 230.
Digital rights groups, which opposed Simington's nomination,
criticized the Senate's move.
The organization Fight for the Future said Simington is likely to “continue Trump’s senseless attacks on the First Amendment and Section 230 of the
Communications Decency Act."
Free Press general counsel Matt Wood called the confirmation “a cynical Republican ploy to deadlock the Biden FCC.”
Wood added: “A
functioning FCC ought to matter to Senate Republicans too, as their constituents also suffer from the digital divide and the lack of competition, diversity and localism in media ownership. Yet
Republican lawmakers voted the wrong way when told to do so by a defeated president and their obstructionist Senate majority leader.”
The group Public Knowledge added that a deadlocked
FCC “could jeopardize every technology initiative from expanding affordable broadband access to reinstating net neutrality rules.”