Commentary

It's Time For A Fact-Checking News Show -- On Linear TV

As checking news content on traditional TV, social media and elsewhere becomes increasingly important, there is a need for a new type of broader TV network/platform that confirms, summarizes, and could fact-check information from different news organizations.

But here’s the thing. It must be easy to understand. The Verify web platform from TV station group Tegna is a good start, and it needs to go further.

Verify offers explanations of things, about two minutes long -- such as whether you need to pay taxes on cryptocurrency, or confirming that President Biden never told Americans they would receive a new round of stimulus payments, or whether the gas you are putting into your car comes from Russia.

Other fact-checking websites offer detailed results focused on specific, in-depth stories. But the average TV news consumer or digital media consumer may be short on time when it comes to figuring out what’s what. Going to multiple sources of news information can be a chore.

advertisement

advertisement

And there is the factor of demographics. Older consumers still go to linear TV for their news, while younger people are more apt to use digital media.

Mind you, this would not be an easy task -- even for producers and reporters to check. And, even then, some explanations can seem complex.

For example, “MSNBC Reports” on Tuesday had a segment that discussed the recent incident on a live news broadcast of Russian-owned TV network Channel 1. In the middle of an on-air video of a news presenter/anchor, a woman appeared behind the anchor with a handmade sign with a message that included the words “No War.”

Reports from U.S.-based news organizations said the woman was a staffer at the network, and she was arrested after the incident. Her name was not disclosed.

After the incident, a Twitter account under the name “Marina Ovsyannikova” popped up, according to MSNBC, purporting to show through tweets her unhappiness about the Russian invasion of Ukraine. As it turns out, the account is fake. The account was only recently created, says Savannah Sellers, anchor/correspondent for NBC News.

“These are all red flags, showing something that looked like it could have been fake [the video of the protester on-air] was real, and then a fake event comes after that,” she says.

Another report on a video of Ukrainian schoolchildren walking into their new school in Naples, Italy was real. NBC was able to confirm this video from posts of parents, as well as finding that the school, on Google Maps, actually exists.

Now, imagine a special half-hour news show of this type being aired every day -- covering these news reports in terms of fact-checking and other references.

While some news content might need heavy analysis that would take a long time to explain, much of it can be done in short video segments, like what Verify is doing.

But will people really watch this? Perhaps -- dare I say -- there can be an “entertaining” way to deliver this type of news story.

2 comments about "It's Time For A Fact-Checking News Show -- On Linear TV".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Ed Papazian from Media Dynamics Inc, March 17, 2022 at 10:39 a.m.

    Wayne, a far  better way to handle this kind of situation---were it possible to do so---would be to require the offending network, news media, social media network, publisher---whatever----to run a fact check "correction" notice for each infraction a set number of times across its full content schedule to make sure that most of its viewers, readers, listeners, etc. were exposed to it. Do that and the media would very soon begin to seriously police themselves.

    Speking about self-policing, a case in point is the fact that in response to congressional investigations about false and/or misleading TV commercials long ago,  the broadcast TV networks began to review every commercial they transmitted---before it went out to the public---and, in effect, fact check them. If a dubious claim was made, the advertiser was required to show proof---usually a survey----that it had a basis for its claims. For years the stations  relied on the networks to pass judgement on national spots before presenting them, locally, but I don't know what they did about home area advertisers re fact checking. I assume that this system is still more or less in place for TV commercials at lest.

  2. Ben B from Retired, March 17, 2022 at 11:11 p.m.

    I don't see it working in my opinion on a fact check TV show you'd still have a lot that say they wouldn't believe who was fact-checking the story or saying fake news. I'd check out the show to see if it was or not I wouldn't watch it every day/night. The media isn't going to police themselves other than local news.

Next story loading loading..