Cars aren't just products -- they're badges that reflect a driver's identity. When David Ogilvy famously advertised Rolls Royce by highlighting the quiet ticking of its dashboard clock, buyers
weren't purchasing silence; they were signaling success. Great brands understand that product features justify emotional decisions -- but ultimately, consumers buy what brand
association says about them.
Tesla once exemplified this understanding, symbolizing innovation, technology, and environmental responsibility. But today, Tesla faces a
profound brand crisis because the company's identity is inseparable from its controversial founder, Elon Musk.
Musk is undeniably a relentless innovator -- he famously
slept on the factory floor during production crunches. Yet Tesla’s current challenge isn't rooted in product issues. Product problems are fixable; Johnson & Johnson demonstrated this decades
ago with Tylenol. Tesla's real problem is Musk's tarnished public image, something he's ill-equipped to repair.
advertisement
advertisement
Recent demonstrations across the U.S. explicitly
targeting Musk, alongside President Trump, reveal how deeply Musk's divisive persona affects Tesla’s reputation. Musk’s political antics -- funding polarizing election
campaigns and headline-grabbing stunts -- have further eroded trust in the brand.
Even if Musk stepped away from the spotlight, deleted his X account, and completely withdrew
from political controversies, restoring Tesla's brand would be a slow and uncertain process. Brands damaged by negative associations rarely bounce back quickly, if at
all. But more realistically, Musk is unlikely to retreat fully. He appears addicted to fame, likely more distressed by losing 500,000 followers on X than losing $200 billion.
The dilemma Tesla faces is stark. Musk’s association is toxic to a significant portion of potential buyers, steadily undermining the brand. Yet, Tesla’s stock
valuation still relies on the "Musk Magic." If Musk exits completely, the stock price will collapse even faster than its current steady decline.
The only viable
option may be for Musk to retain a stake but hand operational and selling ownership to new leadership -- someone credible enough to stabilize and rebuild the brand.
However, Musk’s ego and attachment to control make this unlikely. Tesla is caught between the proverbial rock and a hard place: Musk’s continued presence damages the brand,
yet his departure risks immediate financial turmoil.
To genuinely save Tesla, Musk must hand over the keys, stepping aside enough to allow new
leadership to restore credibility without completely removing the Musk Magic premium. Whether Musk is capable of this nuanced move remains the real question -- and the future of
Tesla’s brand depends on the answer.