Commentary

Digital Media 2008: From Reality To Realism

Seems like no matter where you look--from blogs to the trades to headlines laden across business journals and newspapers--the past year has been chock-full-of buzzwords for our beloved digital media industry. At the helm is the most popular label of all, social media. Ah yes it's a nebulous term. Ask 10 people (in or out of the industry) what it means and you are bound to get 10 different answers.

Looking back at this time last year, the industry seemed to have an empty canvas alongside a minimal palette. However, since this time, I'm sure no one would contest that the perceived value of social media has been staggering. In fact, it took many by surprise. Just look at the sheer penetration rates of sites like MySpace, Facebook and YouTube. Or take a step out into a crowd in just about any major city and watch everyone that is attached to a mobile device, be it talking, listening, texting, emailing or using applications.

And through it all we've begun to see who took a leap of faith and built campaigns around environments like blogs, microblogs, social networks, virtual worlds and just about any walled garden out there. We've also begun to see which businesses have chosen the more conservative path of standing pat. In fact, as the value of social media grows more and more irrefutable, it's becoming addictive to watch businesses that demonstrate a complete reluctance to infuse these new marketing possibilities into their deeply ingrained big media practices. The good news is that these cautious practitioners are beginning to see the light. The unfortunate thing is that it took an economic disaster of epic proportions to open their collective eyes.

For traditionalists, especially those heading up the marketing efforts for global brands, the campaign tool kit heading into 2008 was largely comprised of the conventional big ticket items: Print and online display advertising, television and radio commercials, Super Bowl ads and corporate sponsorship of sports arenas. As this aversion to new ideas persevered into the third quarter, the trend made me scratch my head a bit more--especially when I saw the growing number of new, efficiently priced, low-risk options that were gaining increase traction among most consumers. I couldn't help but think, am I missing something?

Then a funny thing happened. The economy imploded and, mired in the first stages of the biggest economic crisis since the Great Depression, many traditional marketers found themselves at a crossroads. Companies could not bury their head in the sand and simply operate as though nothing had happened, all while their marketing budgets began to get heavily scrutinized.

Take General Motors as an example. GM, one of the largest media buyers in the world, recently announced that it would not be airing any TV advertisements during the 2009 Super Bowl. The reason for the move is obvious--GM was implementing significant companywide cost cutting reductions. Now, with the pressure to produce results on a reduced budget, GM has a choice and it's the same one many of the new media-challenged marketers face today. Either take the lead of a brand like Coke, an early new media adopter that has launched a variety of projects designed to complement its more traditional efforts, or ignore all the social media signage and cling onto a model which, while familiar to all and still effective in many respects, does not engage consumers in the manner to which they have become accustomed.

So now the questions we get from these marketers is the following: "where do I go from here? The answer is simple, "Grow up!" and it appears folks are beginning to listen. Take the RFP (request for proposals) process for example. In recent times, I have seen more and more RFPs with at least one dedicated question related to social media. Compare this to a year ago when the question came up with far less frequency. The question itself tends to revolve around the fact that most brands now want to know how social and emerging media could potentially affect their brands from perception down to the nitty-gritty reality of marketing and media tactics.

My answer to them is, whether you're here for the right or wrong reasons, it's finally time for marketers to embrace the one thing that they have been avoiding, social and emerging media. Evolution plays into all corners of our lives and marketing is no exception. Consumers are spending their time differently. Their lives have become more time starved and often times frenetic. They want what they want when they want it. They have an on-demand mentality that will not go away anytime soon. They are spending an increasingly large amount of their time on sites such as Facebook and Twitter. They are also demonstrating greater willingness to let marketers reach out to them in a number of new channels including their most personal of places, their mobile phone. For those at the crossroads, it's time to move into the "smart media" era.

So what's my advice? Simply put, don't react. Take a step back and see what options are at your disposal. I've mentioned some high-profile options such as Facebook and Twitter but there are many more alternatives. Next, take the time to see what other marketers are doing and if it's working. Thirdly, think about what it is you are hoping to accomplish for your brand and how each platform will affect the way customers, both current and future, interact with it. Are you looking to sell products, enhance your image or maybe even both? Lastly, take a chance! If the 2008 Presidential Election taught us anything, it's that social media gives you an opportunity to motivate and mobilize company evangelists to create something truly unique that can literally change the market landscape.

For many businesses, social media was not on their marketing wish list for 2008 or maybe even 2009. The bottom line is that these companies have been ushered into the social media era whether they like it nor not and now that they are here, they would be well advised to open their minds and see what these new tools can do for their brand. What they might discover is that a campaign within a walled garden might be more effective and efficient today than a 30-second spot during the next Super Bowl. We've entered a new world of accountability my friends. So I'll leave you with this, isn't it about time?

5 comments about "Digital Media 2008: From Reality To Realism".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Michael Troiano from Holland-Mark, January 13, 2009 at 9:45 a.m.

    Damn straight.

    It's time for marketing folks to grow up, here's my take:

    "Let’s face it folks… marketing has become what HR used to be, before somebody figured out we were spending more money on people than on anything else. It’s the place where arty intellectuals can travel, interact with like-minded pretty faces over cocktails, and hide from the accountability that has transformed every other corner of the 21st century corporation. Most marketing people are mediocre. Most marketing is the sexy part of sales without the pesky accountability, and it is worthless. Harsh, perhaps, but you know it’s true.

    How did it come to this?..."

    More: http://scalableintimacy.com/?page_id=4

  2. Matt Skallerud from Pink Banana Media, January 13, 2009 at 11:14 a.m.

    Excellent article... during the last downturn in 2001, I found companies felt forced to adapt and thus e-mail marketing and what are now traditional banner ad marketing came into their own. The same thing is happening again today, although with a far more powerful marketing arsenal of tools at everyone's disposal. I believe social marketing with blogs, videos and the various social networks online, and how people interact with them, is the biggest new frontier on the Internet since websites came into their own in 1995.

  3. James Schaffer from Keller Fay Group, January 13, 2009 at 5:58 p.m.


    Interesting piece! Your advice is sound: no need to be reactive, but DO IT. Just by peeking a bit more into how your brand niche (or specific brand) is discussed in social media, you can learn things that will help you market even if you never engage in a direct outreach campaign!

  4. Jason Krebs from Tenor/Google, January 14, 2009 at 11:42 a.m.

    So many people are afraid of taking risks and doing something different. Some fear the unknown, others don't have the personality to take risks. Many people are thankful to have their jobs in a big company and the last thing they want to do is stand up and say "hey i've got a new idea." Sticking with what others have done before you is an easy way out.

    Those of us who want to show people that there is another way, have to keep working every day to prove that "new and different" can equal "better and more effective."

    We all can do better by listening to people like Seana.

  5. Eric Andrade from tba, January 23, 2009 at 5:58 p.m.

    Great post, Seana.

    One great example of embracing the emergence of the digital platform is Saatchi's creative for Miller surrounding the Super Bowl.

    This campaign is brilliant both for its timeliness (appealing to everyone's mood around the economy), and its judicious use of digital to create a lot of great content that would never have seen the light of day if the digital budget had to compete with the spend for :30 during the game.

    http://www.1secondad.com/

Next story loading loading..