Commentary

Mobile Video Ads: Supply Skyrocketing, But Where's Demand?

Recent research by eMarketershows mobile video ad spend is on the rise, up 119% in 2014 alone, with growth projected to outperform desktop video ads for the next five years.

Still, this marketplace faces some surprising headwinds. Contrary to desktop video, premium mobile supply currently far outstrips demand. 

What is causing this trend? Current technological hurdles tell part of the story. For example, the idea that advertisers can increase their reach and frequency by adding mobile video into the mix with TV and other digital ad buys is alluring, but targeting users and reporting across screens is challenging. Cookies don’t work for mobile so, instead, device ID matching is needed, and this technology has a long way to go. 

Additionally, viewability tracking and poor view-through rates (VTRs) on the mobile screen continue to depress the value of the inventory. Until mobile video targeting, tracking and viewability reach the sophistication we are seeing on desktop, it will be a harder sell for performance-based media buyers.

advertisement

advertisement

Also important, the mobile video ecosystem is hugely programmatic compared to desktop. While more and more advertisers are starting to adopt programmatic technologies, it is still a barrier to entry for those who haven’t. Some advertisers still fear programmatic and cannot purchase mobile video inventory because they are not managing their buys through a DSP or agency trading desk.

This imbalance has several consequences. For instance, the growth of mobile CPMs is being stunted. AOL recently shared it is seeing a slight increase in overall CPMs, and growing supply is the only factor keeping CPMs from increasing more dramatically.

Fill rates were significantly lower than their desktop counterpart in Q4 as well. While this can be symptomatic of technological inefficiencies, the high supply and low demand per request is certainly a contributing factor. This predominantly affects longer-tail publishers, as advertisers have the luxury of only buying inventory on the most reputable, top-tier sites because it is so readily available.

Significant advancements are being made to directly address the issues listed above, but the key factor increasing CPMs is that advertisers are finding greater value in mobile advertising. 

Increasingly sophisticated mobile video ad units, including rich-media interstitials, are becoming hugely popular for advertisers. Audience and cross-screen targeting are also improving, thanks to more reliable device IDs like Apple’s Identifier for Advertisers (IDFA) and Android’s Advertising ID. As mobile targeting becomes more refined and measurable, marketers’ confidence and ad spend will rise.

Finally, despite the hesitance of more-traditional agencies, media buyers as a whole are increasingly embracing programmatic. With the majority of mobile inventory sold in an automated fashion through ad networks and exchanges, media buyers need to embrace programmatic technology before they can boost demand.

In the future, it is entirely possible that media budgets will not differentiate between desktop and mobile. As we converge toward a purely programmatic ecosystem, advertisers will laser-focus on reaching certain audiences or achieving certain performance metrics. In this case, it doesn’t matter if impressions are served on desktop or mobile, as long as the campaign goal is met.

The industry has a lot to do before we reach this somewhat idyllic scenario, but all signs point toward its happening. Technical issues like targeting and measurement are being addressed head-on, while programmatic is poised for serious growth as the paradigm shifts towards more automation. Taken together, we can expect to see a serious lift in mobile video demand as the dust settles.

3 comments about "Mobile Video Ads: Supply Skyrocketing, But Where's Demand? ".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Francine Hardaway from ZEDO, April 1, 2015 at 11:15 a.m.

    It depends on what you consider a mobile video ad. Our inArticle unit, which is a video ad that appears in stream, is seeing high demand.

  2. Richard Gillam from DeskSite, April 1, 2015 at 3:02 p.m.

    Solid reporting Jeremy!

    However, we've found a more fundamental resistance to mobile ads in our experiences over the last year selling video ads on our sports network...so much so, that we stopped even offering mobile ads on our network and, in fact, have found better traction by guaranteeing "no mobile ads" in the mix.

    Specifically, it comes down to things like screen size and capacity to emotionally engage (compared to tablets, consoles, laptops, desktops, smart TV's). You wrote: "...it doesn't matter if impressions are served on desktop or mobile..." But it actually does...for instance, if Toyota is going to spend $X dollars to reach Y number of users, they'd vastly prefer those ads were seen on a 'big screen' device, rather than a smartphone - assuming all other things are equal. It comes down to effectiveness; and watching a car commercial on a 4" smartphone simply isn't as emotionally engaging as seeing the same ad on a 22" desktop monitor...moreover, the viewer seeing the ad on a desktop is more apt to engage the brand (on the spot) than if they watch the same ad on a smartphone - based upon their activity ecosystem at the moment; e.g., waiting in line at Starbucks versus taking a mental break at work...

    Point is that mobile video ads will undoubtedly find better traction in the coming years (as you well summarized), but fundamental quality differences between ad units (on mobile versus 'desktop', smart TV, game console, etc.) will maintain a permanent delta between CPM's for these two very different categories...especially when/as traditional TV buyers finally start buying online video en masse...

    Richard

  3. Or Shani from Adgorithms , April 13, 2015 at 10:46 a.m.

    Video ought to be priced on a cubic inch basis: the # square inches displayed X the number inches to viewers’ ears, eyes, and heart.  By these metrics mobile video is worth factorably less than living room video and it remains over priced. However, programmatic will dynamically address these imbalances by optimizing all video pricing for goals, KPIs, and performance. Therefore, in programmatic, we trust.

Next story loading loading..