CAPTIVA ISLAND,
Fla.--Intuit, Cars.com and Lincoln Educational Services are companies in different verticals, with divergent target audiences and customer acquisition models. Yet each one has used analytics and
consumer insights gleaned from search to solve a unique marketing dilemma. Executives from iCrossing and SendTec, among others, shared their case studies on search "in the wild" with Search Insider
Summit attendees on Tuesday.
For Intuit, parent company of the Quicken, QuickBooks and TurboTax brands, the issue was figuring out how to best market its full roster of products
online (including the 13 separate applications under the QuickBooks name). According to Janel Landis, senior director of search strategy and development at SendTec, the first step was to get the
search activity for every product under one umbrella--which was what happened when SendTec took over the account.
"A number of the products were being handled by different agencies," Landis said.
"And there were seven management teams, and they all wanted to bid on the word QuickBooks." So once the SendTec team was appointed as a company-wide search marketing resource, they got to work
figuring out whether running multiple paid search ads with Intuit's branded keywords (like "QuickBooks") was an effective strategy. On paper, it seemed like one of the best ways to segment the amount
of traffic and leads each product was driving, as well as dominate the search landscape for Intuit's vertical.
But SendTec quickly discovered that it was not a winning strategy. The simultaneous
ads tended to cannibalize the budget and drive up average costs-per-click (CPCs). And even when the ads were served in rotation, the more effective ad was only being served half the time.
"ROI
decreased, and we found that consumers were better served by one ad that allowed navigation to various products throughout the site," Landis said. SendTec also helped Intuit develop a set of rules of
engagement across subdivisions for complementary bidding practices, multivariate testing and knowledge sharing.
With Cars.com, search data helped influence the company's mobile Web site design.
"We soft launched the mobile site in April of 2007," said Dan Perry, SEO manager at Cars.com. "We wanted to extend the Cars.com brand and develop an ad channel for future growth."
In roughly a
year, traffic to Cars.com is up to over three million page views per month. Perry said the growth has been sparked by continuous site improvements built upon user search patterns. "We have an in-house
usability lab, and found that most people search for used cars, then new, and then Kelley Blue Book info," Perry said. "So we optimized the navigation path and put used car search as the first link."
New car search and then Kelley Blue Book links follow, respectively, to minimize the number of clicks it takes to get the most-requested info.
Perry also said that Cars.com eliminated drop-down
boxes in favor of scrollable links, to make it easier for mobile browsers to access content. The company included a prominent search by ZIP code option, which will allow them to serve geotargeted auto
ads in the future. Cars.com also used search data to get a clearer picture of who the typical mobile searcher was, and found two distinct customer types. "There are users on the lot, in the late
stage, physically standing next to the car," Perry said. "They're seeing if the sticker price matches what they saw online, or going through and searching in a 5- to 10-mile radius for a lower price."
Perry said that the other segment was an early-stage shopper, or potential car buyers that were looking at reviews, blogs, photos and original content like top 10 lists. And like the ZIP code
info, in time, the search data will allow Cars.com to serve mobile browsers the most appropriate ad.
Meanwhile, Lincoln Education Services, an adult education organization with some 37 campuses
across the U.S., tapped iCrossing to use search to inform the redesign of their entire Web site. "We used market research, persona development and search analytics to help identify, target and engage
the Lincoln's different audiences," said Rob Garner, strategy director at iCrossing.
The organization includes schools like the Center for Culinary Arts and Southwestern College, so the Web site
needed multiple entry points as opposed to one "start page" so that users could arrive from a search for keywords like "culinary careers" and "culinary careers in Florida" and not land on a
disorienting page.
Before tweaking any HTML code or choosing a color scheme, iCrossing delved into the personalities of current Lincoln students with focus groups and one-on-one interviews, to
find out how they perceived the brand. The agency also used search data to come up with a linguistic profile of each division's target audience, in addition to forming a set of competitive terms. "We
said, here's where you are, and here's where your competitors are, when it comes to these words," Garner said.
Armed with the insights, iCrossing presented Lincoln with the redesign plan, which
was to be measured by stats like site traffic, length of visit, and number of leads generated. And the results were stellar. "The site relaunched in August, and leads were up by 54.9%," Garner said.
By September, October and November, the number of leads generated increased by 74%, 123% and 113%, respectively."
The SEO benefits of the redesign were also quite positive, as Lincoln Education
Services averaged first-page rankings for 294 of their chosen keywords post-relaunch. In contrast, the Web site only garnered first-page rankings for 11 keywords in the previous months.