Commentary

Marketing Budgets, And Accountability, Increasing

According to a recent study by Forbes Insights, in association with MarketShare Partners, on the topic of measurement and accountability, companies are not cutting back on marketing despite the recent economic roller coaster. Three quarters of marketing executives who responded to the survey noted that they expected their marketing budgets to stay the same or increase in their 2010-2011 fiscal year, with fully one-third expecting an increase.

And, measurement is not taking a backseat to the overall campaign development process, says the report. Marketers' focus is split equally between the importance of the "big idea," a core theme guiding all marketing initiatives and programs, and developing accountability metrics.

Interestingly, marketers with budgets of less than $1 million favored metrics (58%), whereas marketers beyond the $1 million threshold felt that having a "big idea" was more important (58%).

Attribute Most Important To Marketing Strategy (% of Respondents)

 

Budget $1 million +

Budget less than $1 million

Total

Tools and metrics that measure ROI and ensure accountability for outcomes

40%

58%

49%

A core "big idea" that guides all of our marketing initiatives

58%

38%

48%

Other

2%

5%

4%

Source: Forbes Insights, July 2010

The marketing department shares a significant portion of the responsibility for marketing accountability. 55% of total respondents noted that the CMO is ultimately accountable for marketing effectiveness within their organization, a proportion that increases to 71% for those with marketing budgets greater than $1 million.

40% of respondents said one of the biggest drivers for developing marketing measurement and accountability programs was to justify spend to senior executives. 65% wanted to make marketing more strategic within their organization. As the average tenure of the CMO is a scant 28.4 months according to Booz & Co., CMOs want to prove their strategic effectiveness, concludes the report

Issues Driving Development Of Marketing Measurement And Accountability Programs (% of Respondents)

Issue

Budget $1 million +

Budget less than $1 million

Total

Make marketing more strategic and impactful within the organization

71%

63%

65%

Senior executives demand some justification for the money we're spending

56%

23%

40%

Improve marketing team accountability

35%

33%

30%

Increased competitive pressures

27%

28%

30%

Financial pressures

25%

30%

26%

Changes in consumer behavior

17%

28%

24%

Need to improve business planning

15%

28%

21%

Need to guide product development

8%

25%

17%

Need to improve advertising agency relationship and effectiveness

6%

13%

8%

Source: Forbes Insights, July 2010

As organizations continue to feel the effects of an uncertain economy, they are seeking new ways to maintain their edge and remain nimble. Marketers cite the desire to remain competitive, the current economic climate, internal financial pressures, changing customer behavior, and addition of new marketing tactics as the top issues driving changes in their needs for analytics.

Extent To Which Selected Issues Are The Driving Changes In Needs For Marketing Effectiveness Analytics (% of Respondents)

Issue

To a large extent

To a small extent

Not at all

Don't know

Desire to remain competitive

65%

24%

8%

3%

Current economic climate

55

32

13

0

Internal financial pressures

52

38

1

0

Changing client/consumer behavior

50

32

14

4

Addition of new tactics to our marketing program

49

 32

16

3

Shifts in marketing strategy to new media

43

 35

18

4

Launch of new products or services

42

41

13

4

Shifts in our marketing strategy toward more easily measurable approaches

37

41

18

4

Deeper scrutiny by executives

36

40

18

6

Source: Forbes Insights, July 2010

In keeping with the internal financial pressures to justify marketing spend and demonstrate ROI marketers report experiencing, measurement's role appears to be proving the impact of marketing on the bottom line. Nearly six in 10 respondents (59%) use "lift" impact on sales volume and revenue to measure the success of their marketing programs; more traditional, customer engagement-oriented metrics such as cost-per-acquisition and brand awareness trailed distantly at 42% and 41%, respectively.

A gap exists between the use of specific measurement resources and respondents' satisfaction with them, concludes the report. Respondents' measurement programs are overwhelmingly managed with internal resources (86%). At the same time, respondents were not as likely to believe that the measurement resources met or exceeded their needs. Three quarters of respondents felt that internal data met or exceeded their needs compared to 92% that currently used it or had done so in the past.

Resources Used To Measure Marketing Programs (% of Respondents)

Resource

Currently Use

Plan To Use In The Future

Have Used In The Past

Internal data

6%

4%

6%

Internal teams

74

7

10

Third-party data

58

15

17

Internally developed tools

52

13

15

Third-party tools

46

18

13

External professional services

35

16

28

Fully outsourced

14

11

24

Source: Forbes Insights, July 2010

 

Satisfaction With These Measurement Resources (% of Respondents)

Measurement Resource

Exceeded needs

 Met needs

Did not meet needs

Internal data

8%

67%

19%

Internal teams

5

65

17

Third-party data

5

60

17

Internally developed tools

5

52

18

Third-party tools

4

53

11

External professional services

5

46

13

Fully outsourced

1

24

15

Source: Forbes Insights, July 2010

56% of respondents reported having formalized systems in place to measure effectiveness and ensure accountability. This may be changing. One third of respondents said that they planned to have formal measurement systems in place in the future, while one in five respondents with marketing budgets greater than $1 million said the same, suggesting that nine in 10 marketing executives will have some sort of formal measurement system in the foreseeable future.

Please visit Forbes here for more details and access to the complete study.

Next story loading loading..