The Comfort Of Nostalgia TV

There are 500+ channels on digital cable — sitcoms to classic movies to foreign nets. The sheer size of selection can be overwhelming and, at times, depressing.

The how-low-can-you-go talk shows demean the human spirit, while reality dating shows often have contestants pimping themselves out. While I’m a fan of HBO and Showtime’s dramas, they're an investment.

Sometimes, you just want to pretend the world of economic turmoil and terrorism doesn’t exist, that health care is affordable, and the middle class still exists. In short, to quote the definition of nostalgia: “a sentimental yearning for the happiness of a former place or time.”

For many, that's MeTV and Antenna TV.

Assuming that your version of happiness is black-and-white shows where everything is sewn up nicely — even crime on “Dragnet” is sanitized — tune in. Viewers get to revisit the late '50s, early '60s — a blissfully one-dimensional TV past.



Don’t misunderstand. That can be hugely comforting when you’re stressed. The machinations of “The Sopranos” or the intricacies of “Mad Men” are complicated, nuanced and compelling.

Conversely, watching “The Patty Duke Show” is a breeze. Duke plays twin teens — “Cathy, who's lived most everywhere, from Zanzibar to Berkeley Square,” while Patty “loves to rock and roll, a hot dog makes her lose control.” The catch: both girls enjoy good relationships with parents. Patty’s “Poppo,” a newspaperman who works an enviable 9-5, talks to the girls in a sensitive, adult fashion.

So do the adults in “Family Affair,” in which a bachelor uncle with a Manhattan apartment I’d kill for, and a British valet, Mr. French, talk to a teen girl and 7-year-old twins in an attentive, caring way. Adoption never looked so good.

Here’s the amazing thing: The kids listen! They don’t contradict their elders! They never crack wise! The “Leave It To Beaver” boys call their father "sir"! Life can be goofy, but it's respectful. There is a name for such scripts: fantasy TV. Unlike Axl, the snarky teenager in “The Middle,” who favors boxers and torturing his younger siblings, or Haley, the pretty but sarcastic daughter in “Modern Family,” TV kids in earlier eras value family harmony. Writers put a premium on one-plot scripts: Beaver gives a girl a locket; Patty edits the school paper. At least by Hollywood standards, life was simpler. A basic bike was a big gift, a fraction of the cost of an iPad.

One of my favorites, “Naked City,” is a portrait of vanishing New York. The cast of actors who appeared in the police show is now legendary, such as Dustin Hoffman, Robert Duvall and Robert Redford. The architecture alone is memorable.

Even crime shows like “Perry Mason” wrap up nicely. Usually, Perry asks some semi-piercing question and the defendant on the stand conveniently crumbles. “The Closer” it isn’t. “Dragnet” is based on real cases in Los Angeles. Like “Naked City,” the dialogue is clipped and sparse, but sans any graphic portrayal of violence. It did, however, create the template for future cop shows, though Sgt. Joe Friday never fails to discuss lunch.

Say what you will about kicking back with a cocktail. If you want to pretend that families are always friendly, a haircut costs $1 and the world is a sane place, head up the cable dial.

5 comments about "The Comfort Of Nostalgia TV".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Steve Beverly from Union Broadcasting System, August 27, 2014 at 2:45 p.m.

    Fern, the problem is, in my opinion.....what we largely receive from Hollywood and television, in particular, today is a one-note theme that ALL of life is dysfunctional. Families do still exist who love each other, despite daily roadblocks. I work with people who are cordial and respectful. Characters on the Emmy-winning "Modern Family" or its many clones do not resemble many people whom I encounter on a daily basis.

    I am unapologetic for drifting to ME TV or Antenna TV at any time. Maybe that's why many of us are hopeful that Bill Cosby can deliver a genuinely family-oriented comedy again on NBC. I truly believe a hunger exists for something we can laugh at and not feel as if every character needs to visit a psychiatrist.

  2. Larry steven Londre from Londre Marketing Consultants, LLC and USC, August 27, 2014 at 3:16 p.m.

    Does anyone challenge the numbers which are given in headlines and body copy? How much hyperbole is in that 500+ number "500+ channels on digital cable." I see Directv delivers 285+, Time Warner 300+, and research shows only about a dozen are used by the typical viewer, so why the hype. What is the truth?

  3. Edmund Singleton from Winstion Communications, August 28, 2014 at 9:08 a.m.

    Yes, there are times when I just want to get away from it all and do so with Antenna TV, further without an on-screen logo where I live makes it even better...

  4. Edmund Singleton from Winstion Communications, August 28, 2014 at 9:16 a.m.

    I forgot to add that with Amazon Prime one can go back in time anytime, just watched three Milton Berle shows without commercials except some of the ones from the 1950's great fun...

  5. Ed Papazian from Media Dynamics Inc, August 28, 2014 at 12:35 p.m.

    To Larry's question about how many channels are used, on average, a typical American can receive 160-180 channels but in a week samples only about 15 of them. That's a bit misleading, as over longer time frames, the number of channels viewed to some degree continues to grow until, over the course of many months, a typical viewer may have sampled program content on as many as 40-45 channels. To be sure, we are talking averages and it should be noted that the figures for TV's heaviest viewers----who account for 40-50% of the medium's total tonnage ( time spent ) ----probably watch many more channels than the norm. It's also worth mentioning that even though we may sample a lot of channels, many of these samplings are for only 10-20 minutes while other channels are followed with much greater frequency.

Next story loading loading..