A new survey underscores just how much can go wrong between a company's green intentions and consumer perception: On average, 85% of consumers are either unaware of --or cannot recall -- the green
initiatives of companies like Hewlett-Packard, Estee Lauder and Intel, even though those companies are recognized as leaders in sustainability.
The survey, from Grail Research, also found
that while the 84% of consumers who currently buy at least some green products are not letting the recession turn them off to green brands, they are dialing back their purchases. While just 1% of
consumers have abandoned the category, about two-thirds of consumers have changed their shopping behavior because of the recession. Some 41% say they have traded down to more affordable green brands,
while 19% say they are reducing the overall amount of green products they use or consume.
The study also found a surprising number of similarities between the hardcore "dark green" shoppers --
who are typically older, more affluent and more educated -- and "light green" buyers.
advertisement
advertisement
"We were surprised by how many of both types of shoppers compare green products with conventional ones when
making their decisions," Silvia Springolo, a researcher on the report, tells Marketing Daily. "That means that even brands that don't think of themselves as green are competing for green
buyers, and that environmentally friendly products can't just rely on claims that they're green -- they also have to be competitive on things like price and performance."
The study did find,
however, that the dark green group is more likely to head directly to a store's green aisles, with 31% saying they do so, compared with just 2% of light green shoppers.
Some 81% of those in the
survey currently buy green cleaning products, 68% seek out green paper products, and 66% say they buy green fruits and vegetables.
Another somewhat unexpected finding, adds Kate James, a
researcher on the report, was how consumers evaluate a product's environmental impact. "With the exception of packaging, which came up in every category, there is no single green attribute that drives
the purchase of all green products. Each category has a specific green feature that is the most critical for consumers."
In paper and cleaning products, for example, the most important feature is
that the product is biodegradable; in food, recyclable packaging matters most, and for apparel, consumers say they are most motivated by knowing that the manufacturing process causes minimal harmful
emissions. "Green doesn't mean the same for every consumer for every product," she says.
Grail also queried consumers about the green initiatives of such companies as Estee Lauder, Hewlett
Packard, Unilever, Nestle and Intel -- all heavy hitters in the world of corporate sustainability programs -- and found that on average, 85% of consumers had no clue that the companies were doing
anything green.
"The low awareness of these initiatives raises huge questions," says Springolo, "because companies are spending so much money on them. And while green qualities are very
important to consumers, they are not being communicated effectively."
For example, 83% of consumers had no idea that Cisco was a green company, while 79% say the same thing about both Lauder and
Nestle. "These companies are just not getting through to consumers."