my turn


Red Goes White, But What About Green?

It may still be October, but one brand is already dreaming of a white Christmas. For the first time, Coca-Cola is turning its iconic red cans white, all in the name of a holiday cause promotion dubbed “Arctic Home” benefiting the World Wildlife Fund (WWF). I predict it will be one of the most buzzed-about holiday cause campaigns of the year, and the brand would likely agree. In a recent USA Today article, Katie Bayne, president of sparkling beverages at Coca-Cola North America, says simply, "It's the most important holiday program we've ever launched.”

Each can, along with white bottle caps on other Coke products, will feature a code prompting consumers to text $1 donations to the WWF’s efforts to protect polar bear habitats. Coke will offer a consumer donation match up to $1 million (although, interestingly, it’s not clear whether a minimum donation to the WWF has been guaranteed). It’s a bold move by the beverage brand to depart from its classic red in hopes of driving sales during the holiday season, and no doubt the promotion has enormous awareness-building and fund-raising potential for the WWF (a previous Coke partner). The intent seems genuine.



And, yet, the imagery of polar bears on aluminum cans -- tying product purchases directly to protecting habitats -- seems misguided. Aluminum can recycling has reached a high in this country, up to 57.4% in 2010, according to an industry report -- but that still leaves billions tossed in the trash every year, not to mention the toll of water use, production and distribution. And although the polar bear may be Coca-Cola’s holiday emblem, it’s also an unofficial symbol of climate change. It is a contradiction to support an environmental cause without an environmental product benefit or attribute, and it may mislead some consumers about the product’s impact on the environment. Imagery is a powerful driver for consumers who could wrongly conclude that purchasing this product benefits the environment more directly than the consumer-driven donation alone.

The promotion’s dedicated microsite,, currently states: “Beginning this holiday season, the more we text, the more we can protect.” The product will not officially launch until Nov. 1 -- at which time, I hope, the site will also share information about Coca-Cola’s environmental stewardship and will aim to inspire consumers to change their own behavior with this issue in mind. Advertising, as well as mobile and on-pack communications, will provide other powerful opportunities to share this important message. I’ll stay tuned to see whether this white promotion will also have consideration for green.

Next story loading loading..