Brands spent millions
for advertising during the Super Bowl XLV broadcast, trying to wow fans and keep them tweeting on Twitter. Groupon was slammed for making light of Tibet's political turmoil. HomeAway got a thumbs down
for featuring babies being hurtled against a glass wall. And while BMW received recognition for running the first ad in 10 years, most missed the company's message that vows their commitment to the
U.S. economy and manufacturing.
Some companies spent up to $3 million for a 30-second TV spot.
Those measuring buzz, conversations and sentiment didn't waste time collecting data
and analyzing numbers. Zeta Interactive created two buzz measurement categories for winners: ads receiving the most buzz, as well as brands experiencing the best and worst chatter before and after the
advertisements ran.
It turns out the overall buzz around this year's Super Bowl commercials registers significantly more positive than last year's. Leading into Sunday night's game,
expectations around the commercials were relatively low, and the tone about the ads about 72% positive. About 12 hours after the game began, the tone rose from 11% to 83% positive, overall -- up 14%
from last year.
Automotive brands dominate this year's buzz in the Zeta Interactive 2011 Super Bowl Ad Buzz Report, with six out of the Top 10 ads representing the space by Bridgestone,
Volkswagen, CarMax, BMW and Mercedes. Bridgestone's Reply All ad took the No. 1 spot, receiving a 94%
positive score for tone. Beverages like Pepsi and Bud Light contributed 20%, followed by online sites such as E-Trade at 10% and other categories, at 10%.
Bridgestone's ad that depicts the
driver saving the beaver and then the beaver saving the driver defuses problems that Bridgestone had years ago with tire blowouts. It spoke to conservationists who go to any lengths to save animals
and the environment.
The lowest-buzz ads to crack this year's Top 10 rankings registered an 84% positive score for tone -- Mercedes' "Diddy" and BMW's "Changes," according to Zeta
Interactive. Ironically, BMW's ad appeared to have the strongest social message for the U.S. economy, but made less than a stellar impact. Twenty-seven ads received tonal buzz rankings of 80% or
better at this year's game.
The Super Bowl has become a competition for brand recognition -- a launching pad to send a message. "Ratings on the top 10 ads show the Super Bowl has become a
showcase for the best advertising campaigns debuting all at once," says Al DiGuido, CEO and founder at Zeta Interactive. "It's not about buzz for the day, but can the ads sustain the buzz weeks and
months after they have run. It's an investment in brand awareness."
Hulu, which typically publishes Super Bowl Ads, uses the AdZone widget to feature
a real-time leaderboard with live voting results. Volkswagen: The Force took the "Overall Most Liked" Hulu 2011 Super Bowl XLV AdZone Winner, followed by Bridgestone: Carma and Volkswagen: Black
Beetle. Doritos: Pug Attack, Volkswagen: The Force, and Bud Light: Hack Job took the No. 1, No. 2, and No. 3 spots, respectively, for the Most Viewed Ads category. Overall, most women like Volkswagen:
The Force; and men, Bridgestone: Carma.
The honor of being the Overall Most Disliked Ads went to Salesforce: Chatter.com Launch: Still Doing Impossible Things; Salesforce: Chatter.com Launch:
Do Impossible Things; and Go Daddy: The Contract. Overall, California fans click to vote the most, followed by Texas, New York, Washington, and Florida.
Fox-banned ads found a place online, too.
Aside from Hulu, the Alterian Buzz Bowl 2011 results released Monday point to Volkswagen as generating
the most mentions across social-media sites: 10,342. The Volkswagen ad came in at No. 3 for reach, placing it as the most-liked brand based on sentiment.
Alterian's collection of 255,431
conversations identifies Total Number of Mentions; Social Engagement Index (SEI), which measures the number of conversations and reach; Social Sentiment Engagement Index (SSEI), channel usage and
sentiment.
Both Doritos and Pepsi rank high across all three rankings. Chrysler and Mars' Snickers are other well-liked brands based on the SSEI. Groupon's ad generates conversations, but
ranks last in sentiment with nearly 13% of conversations classified as negative, according to Alterian.
"Groupon became a poster child for spending a lot of money and missing an opportunity,"
DiGuido says. "The average consumer looking at that ad missed the connection between human issues in Tibet and eating at a Tibetan restaurant. The message got convoluted and they assumed most people
know their product."