Commentary

If Elon Musk Was The Brand He Was Five Years Ago...

To paraphrase fictional character Lieutenant Colonel Frank Slade, if Elon Musk was the brand he was five years ago, he'd take a flamethrower to this place.

Actually, that's what he was when as founder of The Boring Co., he literally rolled out a line of flamethrowers, but to many, that's what he has metaphorically done to Twitter since acquiring it last year. Bottom line, too.

This morning, brand equity appraiser Brand Finance released findings indicating the brand value of Twitter has fallen 32% in the past year.

The data, which is part of Brand Finance's analysis of the brand equity value of the top 50 media brands, shows Twitter falling eight ranking positions, while the "strength" of the brand fell 11 positions year-over-year.

“The positive outcomes that some anticipated for the Twitter brand have not materialized," Brand Finance Managing Director Richard Haigh says in a statement released with the report, noting, "Brand valuation considers intangible and tangible assets, and Musk has overlooked one of brands’ most important resources: people. Twitter needs to address issues surrounding its reputation and brand equity to return to brand value growth.”

advertisement

advertisement

While Twitter is not alone in the decline of media brand equity value -- Facebook, WhatsApp, Tencent and YouTube fell, as well -- Twitter's drop has been precipitous and Musk's volatile management of it has begun to have negative rub on his Tesla brand too.

By contrast, other major media brands have been ascendant in their brand equity value, especially TikTok (+11% to $65.7 billion in brand value) and Google (+7% to $281.4 billion).

The fastest-growing media brands in terms of equity value are LinkedIn, Instagram, and YouTube (see below).

4 comments about "If Elon Musk Was The Brand He Was Five Years Ago...".
Check to receive email when comments are posted.
  1. Dan Ciccone from STACKED Entertainment, June 27, 2023 at 4:28 p.m.

    I think it's only fair to mention that Musk didn't officially take over Twitter until 8 months ago today and his first order was to get rid of the multitudes of bots.


    Additionally, I'm sure the brand took a big hit when its users found out that the old Twitter guard was in bed with the government and proactively shadowbanning and blocking people for those who had apposing viewpoints - which Musk provided full disclosure.


    Musk also said he wants to transform the platform, experiment, and not rely so heavily on advertising.  It's a work in progress that's been interesting to watch and not the train wreck the media would like us to believe it is.

  2. Hal Brown from Delta Media replied, June 27, 2023 at 5:18 p.m.

    Dan, I couldn't agree more. Very well said. 

  3. Robert Rose from AIM Tell-A-Vision, July 7, 2023 at 4:44 p.m.

    Dan and Hal - I couldn't agree less.. nor could the millions of users currently migrating over to "Thread" from Twitter... but don't let the facts get in the way of your blind ideology. 

  4. Hal Brown from Delta Media, July 7, 2023 at 5:06 p.m.

    Robert, thank you for your comment and your assumption of my "blind ideology". Did your response make you feel better? I hope so. Carry on.

Next story loading loading..